Remix.run Logo
▲ wyager a day ago

The point of shooting in a log format isn't to make the footage look a certain way; it's to reduce the degree to which quantization/clipping throws away information you want to have in post.

If you film with a standardized transfer function like HLG or S-Log3, you should be able to apply the inverse OETF in your grading software and work in whatever color space you want (linear, ACEScct, etc.). If you want, you can just compress to rec.709 there! There's really no need to squash to rec.709 in the camera.

▲kstrauser a day ago | parent [-]

I know zero about video but a decent amount about digital audio. What you said sounds, by analogy, like we don’t use 24-bit masters because we need that dynamic range (we absolutely do not) but so that we have enough extra bits to adjust the dynamic range without introducing a bunch of noise into the mixing process.

Is that about right?

▲Melatonic a day ago | parent | next [-]

Sort of. The problem is most cameras record in H264 and now (finally) sometimes higher than 8 bit depth.

That's like using a low quality audio codec as your master.

Recording in log squeezes the maximum amount of usable latitude into an otherwise not ideal codec.

▲KaiserPro a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Kinda.

Its a hack to get the result of 24bit.

24bit means that you have way more dynamic range than you can possibly want. log is a bit more like slapping a compressor in to capture something like a snare without needing the full 24bit. You set the compressor to open right at the start but then close off as it get louder.

log film space means that the darkest darks get way more precision, falling off exponentially as they get brighter and brighter.

▲t0bia_s a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Not good analogy. Log in video means more noise in shadows because lowest ISO is higher. Does 24bit sound need a more gain that increasing noise?

▲Melatonic a day ago | parent [-]

Log theoretically doesn't mean that but it does often implement like that. Usually it shoots at the real base iso of the sensor and doesn't allow changing (or for dual base gain sensors they often have a second log setting for low light with the second "base" iso)

▲t0bia_s 17 hours ago | parent [-]

On Sony or Fujifilm that I used, ISO <800 (or 1000) is disabled and can be changed higher only. Never fixed.

▲Melatonic 16 hours ago | parent [-]

That's because on those sensors that's the "real" iso of the sensor. Below that is just it doing some ADC mumbo jumbo.

▲t0bia_s 16 hours ago | parent [-]

Not true. ISO depending on log. F-log has ISO 800, F-log2 has ISO 1000, same sensor.

▲wyager 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

It's more like you only have the ability to save 12 bit samples due to bandwidth limits, so instead of recording 24-bit linear signal amplitude, you u-law compress the waveform before saving to disk as 12-bit.