Remix.run Logo
▲ otterley 4 hours ago

You realize that spies don’t come with calling cards, right? Do you think our own agents can be so easily unveiled in foreign countries?

▲nixon_why69 3 hours ago | parent [-]

But the default assumption is that I'm not a spy, you're not a spy, she's not a spy.

China's government also made it illegal to import nvidia hardware, there's 600k H200s (!) stuck in a warehouse in Hong Kong right now[1]. So it's at the very least a little weird that a Chinese government spy would be breaking Chinese law all day long as her day job.

[1]https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/almost-600000-nvi...

▲otterley 3 hours ago | parent [-]

> But the default assumption is that I'm not a spy, you're not a spy, she's not a spy.

That’s a very convenient default that benefits spycraft.

I have no idea whether Alice Huang is a Chinese spy or not; we may never know. Regardless, Jensen Huang may have broken the law by using the Singaporean front company for whom she allegedly worked to funnel export-restricted chips to China. If she was also a Chinese spy that he was also schtupping, that would have been frosting on the cake.

The story you linked to says “Approximately 600,000 Nvidia H200 chips destined for mainland China are currently being held in Hong Kong, awaiting import approval from the Chinese government.” There’s no mention that China makes the importation unlawful, and it would be an odd thing to say if it were. Do you have a trustworthy source that says it is illegal under Chinese law to import them?

▲nixon_why69 3 hours ago | parent [-]

> That’s a very convenient default that benefits spycraft.

There's 1.4 billion Chinese. Let's say 50-100 million of them have decent English. You gonna assume every Chinese you meet is a spy? Can we examine why everyone just said "oh yeah of course she's a spy" based on zero evidence and require evidence that she's not?

> Do you have a trustworthy source that says it is illegal under Chinese law to import them?

Here's a link from when the ban went into place earlier this year, it made news at the time. It appears to be more of a "policy" thing than a "law" thing. https://www.reuters.com/world/china/chinas-customs-agents-to...

▲charlieyu1 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

She worked for state media before the current role. Even if she is not a spy, she is connected to the Chinese government in some way.

And likely a CCP member simply for the roles she was allowed to hold. There are ~100 million CCP members, most wealthy Chinese are members.

▲nixon_why69 12 minutes ago | parent [-]

Given that there are 100m CCP members, why would that indicate a given one is a spy? At those numbers, it just becomes a normal part of getting ahead. It's like thinking Americans who recited the pledge of allegiance as kids is meaningful.

▲otterley 11 minutes ago | parent [-]

You seem unusually insistent that she’s not a spy. What’s your angle, exactly?

▲otterley 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> You gonna assume every Chinese you meet is a spy?

Of course not. I leave that determination to subject matter experts, based on the available evidence, like a good engineer should. We may never know whether she is for sure. I think “maybe” is a perfectly reasonable position to hold.

> Here's a link from when the ban went into place earlier this year, it made news at the time. It appears to be more of a "policy" thing than a "law" thing.

Do we know whether this position was still held as of Q3 this year? This story was from back in January.

▲nixon_why69 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Based on 600k H200s being stuck in Hong Kong, it appears the policy is still in effect. That's a lot of money to be parked in a warehouse.

And, no, "maybe" is an extremely paranoid assumption to hold about any random Chinese person. The % of people in the world who are spies is really small. It says something about the overall media environment that people just uncritically go with "sure, spy" on zero evidence.

▲otterley 2 hours ago | parent [-]

You understand that the word “maybe” is not identical to “probably,” “likely,” or “certainly,” right? They are different words in the English language with different meanings. Is English your first language?

You also realize that Alice Huang isn’t just some Chinese rando who happens to speak English, right?

You seem awfully defensive. Perhaps we should wonder why.