Remix.run Logo
▲ areoform 4 hours ago

What made Steve Jobs great was that he would rather have Apple cannibalize its successful product lines than fall prey to a competitor. You can see this pattern with the iPod. The iPod disrupted itself many, many times. The iPod Mini then the iPod Nano. Then the iPod shuffle as the answer to the race ot the bottom.

The biggest moment was partnering with Motorola as phones started becoming more capable and flash memory got cheaper to bring music to phones, which was then the prelude to the iPhone.

The iPhone killed the iPod. Most companies would have never created the product, because it would have killed their golden goose, but Jobs did.

Just like he went all in on the iPad which had the potential to kill the cheap student Mac.

If Nvidia's next CEO is smart, they'd buy up a bunch of these companies that "burn" weights to silicon, make the process better, and then sell that as a service. Let it cannibalize the sales of their products. It's better for them to do it to themselves than their competitors.

▲usefulcat an hour ago | parent | next [-]

> Most companies would have never created the product, because it would have killed their golden goose

It's not a tough sell for a hardware company; in fact it's completely normal and happens all the time. They release a newer version of a product around the same time they stop making the previous version. Bonus if the newer version is cheaper to manufacture too.

> Just like he went all in on the iPad which had the potential to kill the cheap student Mac.

From Apple's POV, is an iPad more like a cheap student Mac or a larger iPhone (but without being a good replacement for an iPhone)?

I think the choice to go forward with the iPad makes a lot more sense from that perspective. The potential iPad market is larger due to the generally lower price, and the margins on a "cheap student Mac" are by definition not great to start with. If iPad margins are similar or better then it would be a win even with 100% cannibalization.

▲rr808 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yes you're right but since he left Apple has become much more successful. Sure it isn't as innovative as it could be but still its #1 in pretty much everything consumer hardware. It isn't the most valuable company in the world for nothing.

▲2costcardnow1 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> but since he left Apple has become much more successful.

From momentum. Apple is a lifestyle brand. There is no reason for the normal consumer to want the latest iPhone over the latest two iterations. And yet, a lot of the new owners got it from Model -1 tradeins, because it has the one thing the other ones dont" identifiable camera configuration when seen from the back. It signals "I own this".

95% of software products hold their seat because they got the seat in the first place years ago, and not because they're necessarily the best.

▲robotresearcher an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Yeah I largely agree with the momentum argument, except that the M-series hardware is insanely great. Apple in execution mode took the idea of the Mac and made it surprisingly good, leading the whole market.

Also: AirPods are really good, again leading the entire market.

Sadly they have not done nearly as well with the Mac and iOS software, which disappoints regularly.

▲mullingitover an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> From momentum

Tim Cook was in charge of Apple for longer than Jobs' second tenure (and there were very good reasons to fire Jobs on his first try). You might be able to claim momentum if things slowed down after Cook took over, but instead it seems to have accelerated: Apple under Cook shipped a good amount of new product lines and services.

Plus: Cook was there since the start of Jobs' second tenure. You could make a good case that Apple's miracle turnaround and product line discipline doesn't happen at all without Cook in the COO role.

Overall Jobs was a great head coach, but Apple is an all-star team. With their level of talent there are plenty of coaches who can deliver great results. Jobs did give a great demo, though.

▲__MatrixMan__ an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

> It signals "I own this".

This is funny because few companies are worse than Apple when it comes to acting like their users don't own the hardware.

▲riddlemethat 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If Jobs hadn’t rebuilt Apple after returning it wouldn’t be here today. Many seemed to agree it was over.

October 6, 1997: Michael Dell makes an incredibly bleak appraisal of Apple’s fortunes, uttering a quote that will become notorious. Asked what he would do with the struggling company, the founder of Dell Inc. says he would “shut it down and give the money back to the shareholders.”

▲bathtub365 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

What else could he say? He was running a competitor

▲altcognito 2 hours ago | parent [-]

I don't know how old you are but seriously, only the most fanatical Apple users were left for many years. What he is saying isn't particularly controversial.

Their contributions outside of the personal computing market is really what saved them overall. Sales were pretty flat until 2004, at which point their ipod devices really were cranking along and started pumping the overall brand.

(The switch to a nix system was great, but it didn't drive sales enough.) In my perspective, it wasn't until they left intel that their machines got significantly better, which is funny, because I respect the hell out of intel, but apple was right to focus on better performance per watt and less hot machines.

▲dofm 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Two things saved Apple before we got into the 2000s: $150M from Microsoft [0] and the blue-and-white products (the iMac and the PowerMac G3).

Everything after that happens in the light of the absolute knockout success of the iMac, which got a staggering amount of good press and bought them so much earned media because it was such a product-placement-friendly device; as was the original iBook.

(My low key odd belief is that one of the biggest positives of that era for Apple was the Mac version of Outlook Express. I think we forget just how much easier the iMac made going onto the internet)

[0] you could argue that Apple was, in a way, too culturally important to fail at that moment; Microsoft invested (with non-voting stock) as a way to ameliorate some of their anti-trust circumstances, because the weakened state of Apple was perceived by the press and the world of politics to be partly a consequence of their behaviour.

▲altcognito an hour ago | parent [-]

I forgot about the Microsoft investment! And it's absolutely true that those iMacs were very popular and arguably culturally important at the time. might not have changed the companies revenue big time, but they changed the overall perception of the company from languishing to thriving again)

▲yostrovs 23 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

In 1997 my university's computer science department taught on Apple computers. It was a nightmare. They would take your floppy and not give it back. There was no eject button and you didn't know if it saved your work if you wanted to force eject it by inserting the end of a paperclip into the little hole on the front. Any problem with the computer, the tech would usually tell you to switch to another computer and he would reboot the one you worked on, which would essentially format it and reload a fresh install from the server on it. That was how you'd fix it.

▲bunderbunder 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Worth pointing out, though, that that was hardly a disinterested assessment.

▲SecretDreams 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Are we measuring success by stock price or by revenue growth or some combination therein?

One might say years if the revenue growth under Tim actually came from the decisions made before Tim, by Steve. It's hard to delineate the two. Moreover, you normally extract profit by innovating less so you can focus on margins, but if you do it too much and for too long, your future gets murkier because you've abandoned the mantra that got you successful in the first place.

A classic example of this was Intel, where hubris and bean counters made it rich and then also are what basically killed it. Apple has a bigger moat, but it's not immune to the same sort of fall from grace. Microsoft will probably experience this sooner though, to be fair.

▲Grombobulous an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I don’t agree with this at all. I think you’re just forgetting how long ago Jobs died.

The iPhone X was 5 years after Jobs died.

Apple TV+ was 8 years after.

M1 computers were 9 years after.

The MacBook Neo was 15 years after.

Apple Music (streaming), 4 years after

AirPods, 5 years after.

At some point we can’t just say Jobs made all these decisions ahead of time.

▲marcus_holmes 4 minutes ago | parent [-]

In particular the decision to move away from Intel feels like something Jobs would not have done, and has been critical to Apple's recent success.

▲Danox an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Microsoft is currently in the process of failing under Nadella. Copilot is going nowhere along with the Surface/Qualcomm/Nvidia, Xbox, Blizzard games and last when Sam Altman came calling, they should’ve told him no.

Apple as a vertical computer company controlling the operating system and the hardware puts them in a different league, a league that people/pundits keep stumbling over because they see the rest of the clone world and think Apple should join in. Nadella probably won’t survive Copilot which needs to be a raving success.

Apple making a touchscreen laptop is a small join in with the rest compromise one that will be niche it won’t move the needle. and will be forgotten.

▲marcus_holmes 5 minutes ago | parent [-]

I'm fascinated that MS are making the exact same stupid decisions with Copilot that they did with Internet Explorer: bundle it into everything, don't bother making it good, just trust that the moat around Windows and Office will suffice for adoption. Report adoption numbers based on people forced to use it by their IT department rather than people who actually want to use it. Focus on corporate and enterprise customers because they're easier to get and can mandate adoption by their staff.

I can easily see a point in a couple of years where Copilot is cursed in the same way that IE was, and becomes the same kind of sick tech joke of a system that really hurts the MS brand.

▲khazhoux 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Why do people insist on saying Apple isn't as innovative since Jobs died?

   * Apple Watch
   * Apple Pencil
   * AirPods
   * HomePod
   * AirTag
   * Vision Pro
   * iPhone Duo
   * Titan / self-driving (massive investment in advanced technology, despite not launching)
   * Apple Pay
   * Apple Silicon 
   * Touch ID
   * Face ID
   * ProMotion
   * Metal
   * Swift
   * ...
▲MeetingsBrowser 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Most of these are Apple versions of things that had already been done successfully elsewhere.

Apple did not invent or even popularize smart watches, fingerprint readers, Bluetooth earbuds, smart home hubs, VR/AR headsets, self driving, mobile payments, foldable phones, etc.

About 2/3rd of the Apple versions of these aren’t even the most popular in their category.

▲Danox an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Where is Blackberry, Nokia, Palm, how’s Intel, AMD, Microsoft doing in the mobile world, tablets, Smartwatches, how’s HP, Dell doing whose position would you rather be in if you had a choice? A vertical computer company? With an operating system, hardware, and the ability to create an ecosystem from the ground up?

If it was easy why is Microsoft failing to expand their reach in fact, Microsoft has problems when the playing field is level, how’s their team ups going? With Qualcomm/Nvidia going why are they laying off 60,000 people? Why do so many of their acquisitions go into the dumper in comparison to Apple.

Why is Apple the only big tech company or one of the few big companies that didn’t fall for what Sam Altman was selling AI wise who is making the rounds???

Apple has a tendency to want to try to make the best device and be the most profitable. They’re not interested in having the absolute market share (Wall Street still believes they should be cheap and sell clones) if they were they could be Samsung, HP, Dell or Azus.

▲taneq 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Apple is like classic Blizzard, they don’t (with a couple of admitted exceptions) create entirely new things out of whole cloth, they take proven concepts and finesse the absolute heck out of them.

▲Danox an hour ago | parent [-]

Vertical computer company, if it was easy why are so many dumbfounded by it?, there was a time when there were many companies that did hardware and software together, as one.

I’m looking forward to one company taking Linux and their own hardware, combining it as one, and selling it to the public as an easy to use product, and no, I do not mean being a parasite on someone else’s hardware.

▲jimbokun 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

That is also true of most of the products launched under Jobs.

iPhone is maybe the only one that seemed wholly novel.

▲aag 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I've never understood this claim. The iPhone was incremental, not novel. Palm, for example, had the previous generation.

▲kube-system 35 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

The iPhone was not innovative in being a smartphone, it was innovative in that it defined the now default all-screen form factor.

It was an incremental choice, but it was a bold choice that nobody other than hard-headed Jobs would have done. Common knowledge at the time was that tactile feedback was necessary for any serious use. Analysts thought it would fail because of the keyboard.

Even more than a year later, Google’s response with Android still stuck with a hardware keyboard.

▲gopher_space 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think "modern" might be a better term for this feeling, thinking back to my old phones.

▲AngryData 18 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It seems like people want to revise history to make the iphone some super special snowflake innovation. But I don't think it was, I had a PDA before iphones and knew it was only a matter of time before they became common, I just think the iphone was very well timed with the marketing needed to back it up.

▲Danox an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Palm and Blackberry were crap. Neither company had no clue when it came to an operating system combined with hardware none.

Previous generation going nowhere, just like that French hard drive music company, Arcos?

Palm and Blackberry, despite seeing the original iPhone and having 3 to 4 years to respond, they were utterly clueless and the same applies to Nokia. and Motorola. It was the OS. Google with the help of Eric Schmidt understood.

What was novel to Palm, BlackBerry, Nokia was the OS at the time within the iPhone all three were dumbfounded…

▲LeFantome 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Not even. I mean, he had a strong opinion on the lack of stylus. But iPaq? BlackBerry? Treo? PalmPilot?

▲coldstreamflowi an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think it was more a case of, there was no HUGE new category like the ones Job's oversaw. Categories that others end up desperately trying to copy because they feel behind, the only one I can think of it Airpods.

That said, any company would kill to have a product like the Apple watch, but Apple sold more iPhones last year than Apple watch has sold in its entire lifetime.

A lot of what you mention while cool that Apple have done those things, aren't particularly "WOW!" level stuff, they are just neat things.

I would argue that more damage has been done by having Metal in that it has ended up creating a moat between them and Vulkan software that came along a year later.

Also Apple silicon was started under Jobs when they purchased PA Semi in 2008.

▲Danox 41 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

The response by Apple under Steve Jobs to buy PA Semi, Intrinsity, and Anobit probably came after Steve asked Intel to design the chip for the iPhone and they said no. It would’ve been interesting to be a fly on the wall when Steve hit the roof and said we gotta design something ourselves in-house, and all the people in the room saying/thinking, is he crazy?

▲Grombobulous an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

There was a huge new category: Apple TV+. Sure, Apple wasn’t first, but neither was the iPhone or iPod. Apple making a whole new major media company from nothing is a major accomplishment.

Jobs wasn’t the person who spent a decade taking PA Semi’s heritage and turning it into a chip that beat Intel. That took years of consistency in engineering management, where every single year that team was pushing out improvements.

> but Apple sold more iPhones last year than Apple watch has sold in its entire lifetime.

This is not because the Apple Watch sells poorly, it’s because smartphone product volume is absolutely insane.

▲martin_drapeau 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Those are mostly improvements over mobile and complementary techologies. They could have built EVs but lacked the drive of a visionary founder.

▲prewett 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Also the Touch Bar. I don't think it was a successful innovation, but it was absolutely innovative.

▲glalonde 3 hours ago | parent [-]

The memetouch emojibar? please.

▲hluska 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Can you explain what was not innovative about it? You may want to look up the definition of the word…

▲TheDong an hour ago | parent | next [-]

A 2014 thinkpad had a touchbar (the Adaptive Keyboard, see [0]).

The 2011 Optimus Popularis keyboard [0] also had a very similar LCD screen innovation [1], and I think was the earliest good implementation of this sorta idea.

I think you can argue that it was largely derivative or reasonably innovative based on the fact that it had been done before (with even worse execution), but it hadn't ever been done at such a large scale, so it still felt very new to consumers.

[0]: https://arstechnica.com/staff/2014/01/stop-trying-to-innovat...

[1]: https://www.artlebedev.com/optimus/popularis/

▲ 44 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲meowface 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Well, they're right. It was innovative. It was just bad.

▲Danox an hour ago | parent [-]

Like having a touch screen Mac, which is only a niche product, Steve Jobs was right.

▲magnio 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Apple Watch: released 2 years after Samsung Watch

Apple Pencil: 4 years after S Pen

HomePod: 4 years after Alexa

Vision Pro: 5 years after Oculus Quest

iPhone Duo: 7 years after Z Fold

You can say the Apple ones are better than the stuffs they copied from in whatever fanatical metrics you use, but those aren't evidence of innovation.

▲wisty an hour ago | parent [-]

iPod - "No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame."

▲thighbaugh 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Why do you insist on defending them? Even if you an employee, stockholder and decked out in Apple gear, you aren't gaining anything throwing yourself into battle for them at all. If other people don't agree with your take on Apple, so what they can suffer. Public opinion won't change until the media they consume suggests something else to them for a while in a subtle enough way they will believe themselves clever deducing it.

▲khazhoux an hour ago | parent [-]

I'm not so much defending them, as calling bullshit on the idea that they stopped innovating 15 years ago. It's a ludicrous claim. As I listed, there are a ton of new products and core technologies (some extremely successful) that didn't exist in Jobs's time.

▲jmyeet 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Apple silicon was the inevitable byproduct (IMHO) of Apple buying PA Semi in 2008 for a bargain price I might add. I think Steve deserves a lot of the credit for that one.

I'd say Tim's biggest successes were Apply Pay, the Apple Watch (although this was originally targeted as a luxury item instead of a health/fitness device), AirTags and probably AirPods. Apple Pencil seemed inevitable. Vision Pro? Um, AR is kinda dead. Duo? I think the jury is still out on this in terms of reliability. But we've had other folding phones for years.

I'm still mad Apple has largely abandoned Touch ID. I despise Face ID. Give me, the user, the option. Put a sensor on the back of the phone, you know like Samsung has been doing since the Galaxy ~S8.

▲ an hour ago | parent [-]
[deleted]
▲Danox 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]

▲BobbyTables2 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If Apple is financially more successful it is only because they figured out to extract maximum value from the captive base created by Jobs pushing for so much innovation in the earlier years.

When the iPhone first came out, it was only expensive. Now it’s a full mortgage payment.

Worse, features have remained relatively unchanged since the iPhone 6…

▲ 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲ares623 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The difference is, it was consumers who wanted Apple's products.

For Nvidia's case, it's large companies that want (or can afford) its products. And the majority of people don't want the byproducts that come out of Nvidia's customers.

▲adolph 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> would rather have Apple cannibalize its successful product lines than

I used to think this but don't think the claim holds up. The one instance that it happened was with the transition from iPod to iPhone, a bet on a higher margin product. Since then the Apple sandbagged iPad for Mac and Apple Watch for iPhone. Before then time and time again Apple hobbled perfectly good computers to maintain margin on higher cost products. The Low End Mac website sometimes referred to them as "Road Apples."

▲gyomu 2 hours ago | parent [-]

The main Apple product today is the ecosystem. Apple wants you to give them $X/mo, where X is more or less as much as you can afford, and ideally keeps going up over time.

They’re not letting the iPad cannibalize the Mac or the Watch cannibalize the iPhone because they want you to buy an iPad AND a Mac, a Watch AND a phone.

If there was a world where they could sell 20 million iPods a quarter, they’d bring back the iPod.

▲01100011 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You mean like they did with Groq?

▲refulgentis 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There aren't a bunch of these companies, and the TCO would be nightmarishly horrible. We go roughly 4 weeks between significant model releases at this point. Rest is just free-associating about Apple.

▲cma 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I think the ipod -> ipod mini is just natural upgrade. In both cases they bought out exclusive supply of tiny little harddrives for use in music players (you could still buy them for e.g. a windows CE sleeve like on the iPaq, they only bought exclusivity for dedicated music players). Once someone came out with a new tinier drive they didn't have exclusivity with them and if they didn't buy out exclusivity on it for the iPod mini they would have been destroyed by competitors releasing much smaller music players.

And they could outbid everyone else because of their premium brand, experience, and the margin they were getting.

Zune was able to get access to them with the Toshiba Gigabeat loophole by having Toshiba manufacture the Zune. The deal with Toshiba didn't cover stuff Toshiba manufactured. The smaller drive in the mini was made by Hitachi.

▲spiralpolitik 3 hours ago | parent [-]

The iPod Mini to iPod Nano was the big strategic move. When they killed the Mini it was selling like hot cakes. Apple needed to get the cost of flash memory down and shifting the market to be flash paved the way for the iPhone, iPad, etc.

Apple also has the advantage that they can always grow down the market. The Neo is the perfect example of this. It's easier for Apple to sacrifice margin for market share than it is for a competitor to move upmarket.