Remix.run Logo
▲ blargey a day ago

Why is "suddenly" even necessary? If AI is better than humans at all the work (nevermind ASI), we'll give it all the work eventually. Why wouldn't the majority of current or future peoples want everything to be done better and quicker and cheaper? And doing all the work means having all the control in practice. And if it's so smart, it will wait that O(1) years before trying to doing something that would upset humanity enough to pump the brakes.

Paperwork digitization is a weird comparison. You can't digitize individual bureaucrats/workflows, but ASI and robots absolutely can. Even individual bureaucrats can and will start flapping any form that isn't an immediate rubber stamp at GPT-Asymptote before the "digitization" officially starts, if it's so smart and easy and reliable already.

▲lnrd 14 hours ago | parent [-]

> If AI is better than humans at all the work (nevermind ASI), we'll give it all the work eventually.

Will we? I worked for company where using Google Drive was a nuisance, they still preferred the old ways of sharing files via email. The company operated like that, made a profit, everyone (except me) was happy.

I worked with a consulting company contracting for the government. The quality of their work was abysmal, most of the workers had very low skills and they added almost no value. They could already be replaced probably many years ago with some solid IT system. The company made a lot of money with these contracts.

In big corporations there are people whose job is to keep a spreadsheet up to date, something that could be automated already for a long time.

I went to a local shop to get my dishwasher fixed. The owner didn't have a computer, had a paper calendar with all the appointments. Gave a hand written quote and an hand written invoice. Operated this business for decades and didn't even seem bothered by the existence of any technology at all.

These are just some examples from my experience and I'm sure there are plenty more.

> Why wouldn't the majority of current or future peoples want everything to be done better and quicker and cheaper?

I don't know, go ask all the companies that today still refuse to use technology to do things better, quicker and cheaper.

> Paperwork digitization is a weird comparison. You can't digitize individual bureaucrats/workflows

Yes you can, countless countries did it, Germany is a famous outlier. The comparison is not weird because the point I'm trying to make is that people/companies/governments do not automatically adopt a new technology even if the benefits are plain obvious. They haven't done it so far, I don't understand why they are going to do it for AI. The world outside of the tech bubble is very different.

▲blargey 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Your human consulting company work is itself an example of a mechanism for their replacement. Top-down or bottom-up or anything in between, if humans can do it AGI will make it happen faster by definition. Especially when AGI has the has the ear of voters and officials and consumers and business-owners/starters alike.

You're ultimately proposing that these change-resistant bureaucracies and old-timer shoppes are the mechanism by which humanity maintains an iron grip over all the levers of control and production forever, but the odd local dishwasher repair shop and DMV won't mean much in front of the mechanization of the bulk of farming and transport and medicine and power-generation/storage and housing and manufacturing and any other thing humans do to support the immediate continuation of humanity.