| ▲ | defrost a day ago | |
Sure, is it your position that a majority of popular movements are lead by professors then? As an aside, there's no personal snipe here or stance against yourself or broader arguments - just an extremely raised eyebrow toward this particular snippet. In general I find highly persuasive populists to have an exceptional EQ type intuition about what moves the needle with a crowd or an audience .. which is often not well correlated with notably high "raw problem solving intelligence" of the STEM or even classics literature variety. | ||
| ▲ | ben_w a day ago | parent [-] | |
> Sure, is it your position that a majority of popular movements are lead by professors then? My position is that they're generally led by above-average people. "Professors" is a stand-in to contrast rhetorically with "village idiots". > As an aside, there's no personal snipe here or stance against yourself or broader arguments - just an extremely raised eyebrow toward this particular snippet. :) > In general I find highly persuasive populists to have an exceptional EQ type intuition about what moves the needle with a crowd or an audience .. which is often not well correlated with notably high "raw problem solving intelligence" of the STEM or even classics literature variety. Sure, there's a lot of problems with all measures of intelligence, which is why I (try to always say) "trends". I've just been watching an old episode of the UK TV satirical news show "Have I Got News For You": it is a long running series in which Paul Merton (self-described as having a highest qualification of "CSE ungraded in metalwork"), almost always defeats Ian Hislop (Oxford educated, editor of Private Eye, a satirical news magazine). Including that one time Paul Merton's teammate was literally a tub of lard, and one round of questions (with the tub of lard) were in languages he didn't speak. Paul Merton may have utterly failed at school, but he's clearly very intelligent. LLMs seem to have already reached the "quite persuasive" phase before they even got good at code and maths. Even a very early one convinced Blake Lemoine to make a fool of himself. And non-linguistic AI like the social media algorithms got addictive, likewise, without even being good at the things they're ostensibly for like recommending groups to join and old friends to connect with (though how much Facebook etc. are even really trying to do those things is unknown outside the company). | ||