| ▲ | pron a day ago | |||||||
> Martin Luther, Adam Smith, Karl Marx. All kinda famous for things they wrote, which changed the world because of those writings. You're saying "some very influential people were intelligent writers". That does not contradict anything I said (you inverted the implication). > The village idiots don't generally get heard; the professors tend to be. Same logical mistake. > these things were made addictive by applied intelligence. There's no doubt intelligent things can do harm, but there is no direct correlation between intelligence and power. > An AI that has taken over doesn't need consensus Neither do humans that take over. Why is AI relevant here (especially as it will need the humans anyway)? > Yes. Look at all the people who keep listening to Musk Again, you're inverting the implication. Some people listen to intelligence; some to charisma or faith. I don't see what gives intelligence, artificial or otherwise, extraordinary power. > None of those are more capable of destroying humanity than the other way around. You're wrong. > We have, in fact, entirely eliminated e.g. smallpox, but no disease, not smallpox, not HIV, not even the Black Death, was ever capable of wiping out the entire human species. You keep inverting logical statements. You're saying: humans have destroyed some species, and some species have not destroyed humanity. These don't contradict what I said. | ||||||||
| ▲ | ben_w a day ago | parent [-] | |||||||
> You're saying "some very influential people were intelligent writers". That does not contradict anything I said (you inverted the implication). I said that first, and of LLMs being already, today, more persuasive. You inverted the implication. Also, careful what stones you cast, you're in a glass house with a lot of the logical flaws of the stuff you've said already. At least one each of straw man, false dichotomy, non sequitur, false analogy / irrelevant comparison, whataboutism, false equivalence. Normally I wouldn't care so much, but if you want to make a game of it… > There's no doubt intelligent things can do harm, but there is no direct correlation between intelligence and power. False. Most leaders are above average intelligence. > Neither do humans that take over. Why is AI relevant here (especially as it will need the humans anyway)? Why did you bring it up then? Also, if you want to talk about logical fallacies: > (especially as it will need the humans anyway)?" When you're already saying in your first post "This entire analysis is predicated on the assumption that intelligence confers some unlimited power,"? > Again, you're inverting the implication. Some people listen to intelligence; some to charisma or faith. I don't see what gives intelligence, artificial or otherwise, extraordinary power. LLMs and other AI already demonstrated the power of persuasion to an above average level. I'd say "if you can't see it, that's on you", but precisely because of what it is, that's a little unfair: it's getting used to manipulate already, no reason you wouldn't be among those manipulated in this way. > You're wrong. Prove it. Name any combination of diseases or insects you like that has the potential to wipe out the human species. > You keep inverting logical statements. You're saying: humans have destroyed some species, and some species have not destroyed humanity. These don't contradict what I said. Your own actual words, again: "biological species that are more capable of destroying humanity than the other way around". Your claim is false, I have shown we have more power and your response is simple denial rather than arguing you claim. | ||||||||
| ||||||||