Remix.run Logo
▲ greggoB a day ago

The job of the CEO is to manage the company as well as they can, keeping business good today and ensuring the company has a tomorrow. It is not hard to intuit that this involves both short and long term thinking.

The whole "it's to maximise shareholder value" refrain is not actually a thing, AFAIK, despite it being something people like to keep repeating.

▲Waterluvian a day ago | parent [-]

It absolutely is a thing. It’s the fundamental thing. What you’re describing is just the first in a tall pyramid of answers to the question “how do we maximize shareholder value?”

▲partloyaldemon a day ago | parent | next [-]

Delaware corps have a duty to maximize shareholder value when selling the business. But no us jx require a corporation to unifocus on shareholder value to exclusion of all or any other interest. Nor does maximizing shareholder interest as it’s understood by practitioners ask 7 Deadly Sins performances of greed of its CEOs.

▲wtetzner a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It's not law that corporations have to maximize shareholder value. Boards have plenty of room to balance the interests of employees, customers, communities, and long-term company health.

▲tarheels100 a day ago | parent [-]

Dodge vs Ford Motor Co (1919).

▲recursive a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Whatever kind of thing it is is not a legal obligation.

▲hosh a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It is not the thing in Japan. Japanese corporations are primarily sustained to continue existing, not to return shareholder value. They are very good at that.

Returning shareholder value wasn’t even a thing in America until 1970s. Corporations were originally formed to limit liability in the 1600s. I can’t say that is better or worse. There is a lot of novel approaches that come from this, but the idea of returning shareholder value that was sold to us by hedge funds, private equity, and vulture capital also drives enshittification. Even now, there is no legal obligation to return shareholder value.

▲chrisjharris a day ago | parent | next [-]

Why would investors invest, if a company declares that it has no interest in returning shareholder value? I'm sure that many people do get a kick from supporting companies that they believe in, but generally investment is not done for purely altruistic reasons.

▲vlovich123 20 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Ironically the case that established this principle is one where the investor was trying to purposefully sabotage the company from expanding into the market as they also owned a competitor (Dodge v Ford). So actually this “return shareholder value” was used precisely to put Ford into a straight jacket in terms of expansion while the Dodge brothers grew their business.

▲Frondo 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I imagine that if the company's goals were disclosed, potential shareholders could make that determination for themselves. Not to be snarky but even among investors, who are possibly more a monolith than most groups of people, they are not necessarily all motivated by the idea of "maximize".

▲recursive a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Perhaps there is something between maximization excluding all else and no interest at all.

▲Waterluvian a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Nothing forces a company to cede control of its values to venture capitalists or to go public. And I suspect there’s a lot of private companies that own their destiny and are making moral choices at the cost of revenue.

The legality is an irrelevant distraction. The shareholders have a voice with, if nothing else, their money.

It feels like people are surprised that a public corporation is seeking to do whatever makes people believe it’s worth more. The people who buy or sell are voting on how they believe the company ought to be behaving.

▲2OEH8eoCRo0 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Why don't they pay dividends?

▲ 16 hours ago | parent [-]
[deleted]