Remix.run Logo
▲ TheBlight a day ago

I guess my point is I bet true ASI would break a lot of shibboleths across all ideological boundaries such that, to your point, all people aren't going to accept it. We'll probably all decide it's wrong or broken.

▲pron a day ago | parent | next [-]

Ok, although I don't think that's likely. It will have access to the same information we have, and so I doubt it will reach too many conclusive results that go against scholarly consensus.

▲TheBlight a day ago | parent [-]

And if this expectation is violated... :)

▲pron a day ago | parent [-]

It will be interesting because it means that intelligence doesn't converge, and so "ASI2" could overrule ASI1's findings in the same way.

▲TheBlight a day ago | parent [-]

Consensus takes a time parameter. The consensus about the Earth being the center of the universe didn't survive to the current time. It's likely a subset of our current consensus would also not hold on a long enough timelime especially with improved cognition.

▲pron 4 hours ago | parent [-]

I'm not talking about just any consensus, but scientific consensus, i.e. one arrived at through the scientific method. So far, it's only been broken when it had low confidence to begin with. Otherwise, it's only been refined. In both situations, this typically happens when there's new information.

For some intelligence to conclusively conclude that multiple scientific beliefs, held with a high degree of confidence, are wrong would be astonishing. It would mean either that the scientific method is bad, frequently applied incorrectly, or that conclusive relevant evidence is frequently ignored. Whichever of these is the case, it would also need cast a doubt on the intelligence's own conclusion.

▲intrasight a day ago | parent | prev [-]

>all people aren't going to accept it

You don't have to accept it but you will have to live with it.