Remix.run Logo
▲ jvanderbot a day ago

Yes - that's how the markets are supposed to work. It is the student's responsibility to plan their own lives - and the job market should be part of that. It is not the institution's responsibility to "correctly" govern the life trajectories of their applicants.

If you, dear xhevahir, wanted to buy a math phd attempt and had the chops, you could self-fund the training, courses, and examinations of a Math PhD, and it'd be up to your own abilities to finish.

But nobody, nowhere, would (should!) stop you because "the jobs" aren't there. You could do it because you can find the money to do it.

Asking universities to set their intake numbers according to the perceived demand 5+ years down the road (let alone the coursework + specialization of those PhDs)? Madness - they'd effectively be planning the whole economy at that point.

▲Invictus0 a day ago | parent [-]

You seem unaware that the PhD students are paid to be there; they are not paying anything.

▲geonineties a day ago | parent | next [-]

Sorta. They pay in labor far below the market rate, and working conditions that are abhorrent. Thy also pay a massive opportunity cost depending on the field.

▲compsciphd 17 hours ago | parent [-]

I loved my phd time (and honestly if I retired, I'd strongly consider going back to it at the pay it gave), i basically had to be pushed out the door my advisor telling me "you've done enough to graduate, focus on your dissertation now".

With that said, I do agree on opportunity cost to a large extent, but I've remained employed not because I'm the best software engineer (I think I'm decent, but perhaps I would have been better if as a younger person I was better trained), but because of what I did as a phd student.

▲jvanderbot 13 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You seem unaware that PhD students _can_ self-fund. A PhD student just needs a funding source - often that is a competed resource that the PI controls, but if you bring the money I cannot imagine any professor would turn away a bright student.

In fact, this is what fellowships, NSF research grants, etc are - they are student-specific funding that follows them throughout their PhD.

Source: I finished a PhD partially self-funded (via a combo of finding work (TA) or finding grants or fellowships to fund the RA part for a year or so)

▲_kulang 20 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Hmm I’d say that phd wage + waived tuition is probably equivalent to the remuneration you could get as a graduate. PhD students definitely pay to be there in some way, shape, or form. Only the recent 5 year academic positions look like a job, but they are longer and underpaid for the work components

▲ a day ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]