Remix.run Logo
▲ moralestapia 2 days ago

>they have no right to

You seem to be confusing what feels intuitively wrong with what is actually unlawful. Law doesn't work on feelings. Where are the terms of use? Do they explicitly prohibit this kind of access? How do they define it?

If a website publishes data and provides a public key that automatically allows a browser to retrieve it, good luck arguing that your "security" was bypassed.

Also, OP mentions confidential information. That doesn't automatically make neathack liable. If I publish someone's medical records in a publicly accessible comment here, are you liable for reading them, or am I liable for publishing them on a website with essentially no access controls?

>an actual leak

Got a link? Or "just trust me, bro"?

>I would bet a sizeable amount of money

Unfortunately, my religion prohibits gambling, which we consider degenerate behavior. But by all means, keep the confidence. It would be even more impressive if it came with an actual legal argument.

▲jacquesm 2 days ago | parent [-]

[flagged]

▲ifdefdebug 2 days ago | parent | next [-]

I reread the whole thing and could not find any ninja edits. You are entering the domain of bad faith here.

▲jacquesm 2 days ago | parent [-]

No, I made a simple mistake. The comment I was referring to was collapsed.

▲schrodinger 2 days ago | parent [-]

Edit: Never mind, this is no longer an option — ignore the below (leaving for posterity).

--

It's been an hour — why don't you edit your original accusatory comment so people don't see that and make inaccurate judgements (esp. given the weight your handle carries)?

▲jacquesm 2 days ago | parent [-]

Because I can't.

▲neathack 2 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Wait, what did I do? Where did I "remove a proof of exfiltration"? I'm confused.

▲moralestapia 2 days ago | parent | next [-]

It's sad to see him tripping like that.

He's one of the site's longest-standing users, but his arguments aren't making much sense. I'm sure he can do better, but he's too stubborn to let this go.

I have seen this with a lot of old-timers. I wish this site were a little more relaxed in general.

▲jacquesm 2 days ago | parent [-]

Your concern is appreciated :)

▲senordevnyc 2 days ago | parent [-]

Man, watching you crash out here is embarrassing.

▲jacquesm 2 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Ah, true for some reason this had disappeared from my view:

"What isn’t mentioned in the analysis is that we ran a System 1 decision model on each dataset to determine whether it contained privacy-sensitive data. Using a confidence threshold of 85%, we found that nearly 4,000 websites leaked such information."

This to me is proof that you actually downloaded the data, you would not have been able to present the conclusions that you did.

Anyway, I wish you best of luck with this whole affair, you did a great job at identifying a vulnerability, and then you turned it into an actual data breach. I hope that lawyer is willing to sign off on you having destroyed the data because that might become a very important issue.