Remix.run Logo
▲ EmX_3000 a day ago

Downsides immediately jump out at me, it lacks real DIN MIDI ports, having those irritating 1/8" jacks instead which require an adapter. Built in battery, hopefully not too difficult to replace. I vastly prefer AAs for this use case like the Volcas use. It has a fan, that's not good at all. It looks cheap (look at the bottom photo here https://www.m-vave.com/product?id=fm-1) and not sturdy. Similar to my Elektron Moden Cycles and my Polyend Tracker, a bit flimsy and cheap.

I feel like the Chinese have made and sold enough music gear on behalf of other manufacturers over time that they can technically make the products, but I don't think they understand the market so they will be flawed and toy-grade for a while until they hire some consultants and carefully study the various portable MIDI gear that has succeeded over time. I'm not sure what the electronic music scene looks like in China but I would suspect most of the people involved still use non-Chinese gear and software.

▲anigbrowl a day ago | parent | next [-]

You are out of touch. All sorts of compact gear (even very expensive sequencers like the Oxi One) use 1/8" MIDI jacks because modern consumers prefer compact. People are also used to charging with their laptop via USB, not easily done with AAs, which are also more bulky. It looks cheap because it is cheap, it costs about $60-80, which is half the price of a Volca.

There's a lot of excellent gear coming out of China. Behringer has their factories there, Donner has a range of recreations (not clones) of various classic Roland analog synths, and also make a wide variety of controllers, pedals, and other gear. Ashun Sound Machines makes the Hydrasynth and a few others, one of the most highly regarded digital synths on the market.

▲EmX_3000 a day ago | parent | next [-]

I don't care how expensive things are, 1/8" jacks are terrible for MIDI. They make really expensive cars with those stupid iPad dashboards too, doesn't make it OK. I'm not pleased with the build quality of the Chinese gear I've seen and none of it seems much more innovative or cheaper than anything else out these days. I still await something really great from China. I'm sure they'll figure it out sooner or later but it's not quite time yet.

▲lossyalgo 19 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I got a couple of these FM-1s and they are very sturdy. I've taken them in planes, trains and automobiles, packed into various bags and suitcases and they still work fine after a couple months of abuse. I just pick a random firmware, bring wired headphones, charge the battery and then just jam for hours during my trip and it's always a great adventure. 50 euro + 10 euro shipping + unlimited easy-to-install firmware choices is unbeatable.

▲brudgers a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I don't care how expensive things are

Other people do.

I still await something really great from China

Try the Wall.

▲Lio 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Behringer might only have factories in China but all their design work (cloning other companies’ products really) is done in other countries like the UK and Germany.

A better Chinese example might be ASM and their Hydrasynth.

▲anigbrowl an hour ago | parent [-]

Perhaps so; that's why I wrote about them in the following sentence.

▲glimshe a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You are criticizing a piece of equipment that created a minor revolution in the music market. Think about that. Sure it has flaws, but it brought vibe music firmware to the masses.

▲EmX_3000 a day ago | parent [-]

Korg, Behringer, they revived the cheap and cheerful modern MIDI music device market. We'll have to wait and see what kind of musical impact this has, so far Equipboard is showing one guy with a pic of it.

▲Marazan a day ago | parent [-]

It is not the device itself. It is the rush of gear companies that are announcing their new gear will be open source/sdk available/1st class custom firmware writing support.

The FM1 has started a revolution.

▲bluehex a day ago | parent [-]

I feel like Synthstrom deserves some credit for open sourcing their deluge firmware and supporting a community version, showing us what was possible. FM-1 and vibe coding was the tipping point, granted.

▲robrain a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

No comment on the general criticisms, but jacks for MIDI is unfair, I think. I probably get more annoyed at connecting DIN MIDI with the mix of equipment I’ve got since most of it uses jacks, not DINs, especially the things I’d connect to a M-Vave. I’m resisting the temptation to buy one right now.

▲EmX_3000 a day ago | parent | next [-]

It's not unfair. Looking at my home studio here I have nine different MIDI synths all set up, two require adapters, and for some reason one set of these sets of identical-looking adapters doesn't even work properly on one of my synths that needs 'em. The other takes both, one only likes one pair. It's a huge pain in the ass. Other issue is they come out easily, DIN has a very solid connection and it takes quite some force to remove the connector. Also I'm not entirely sure how good the isolation is on those little 1/8" jacks, proper DIN MIDI connectors are all opto-isolated so you don't get ground loops.

▲ 14 hours ago | parent | next [-]
[deleted]
▲tiborsaas 11 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If you have 9 synths in your setup you are clearly not the target audience of the FM-1, move on, you'll find no joy in using it.

▲ghostly_s a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Literally what are you talking about. the device is barely thick enough to fit a 3.5mm jack, DIN connectors were never on the table. frankly it's a bonus it has MIDI at all. who cares what your $2000 'proper' synths have.

▲EmX_3000 a day ago | parent [-]

Plenty of thinner gear has real MIDI ports. I hate the adapters and USB MIDI. Put a lump on the back, that'd protect the knobs a bit too.

▲davvid 19 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

To be fair, you can get a 3.5 mm type-A MIDI to MIDI DIN adapter cable pretty cheaply. The key thing to know is that it's "type A" so that you don't buy the wrong adapter.

▲InsidiousWombat a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The ass part about jacks is that there is apparently 2 standards for midi over jack, with various gear manufacturers split over which one to use. You can make device accept either but it's pretty rare sight.

Connector wise, far superior to DIN midi

▲marpstar a day ago | parent [-]

There are actually 4 ways manufacturers do it. Something like the Disaster Area Designs[1] MIDI Box is a necessity once you start dealing with guitar effects pedals.

[1]: https://www.disasterareadesigns.com/shop/p/midi-box-4

▲EmX_3000 a day ago | parent | next [-]

That looks brilliant. I thought there were only 2 ways. I really think that MIDI device makers need to be actively bullied into providing DIN MIDI even if they want to stick USB or the 1/8" jacks on too for whatever reason.

▲InsidiousWombat a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I've had A/B solved by just schottky rectifier and low enough current optocoupler, but damn ,didn't knew there is even more to that mess

▲brudgers a day ago | parent [-]

I solder two TRS jacks back to back, squirt hot snot into the gap, and shrink some shrink tube around it…it’s about $0.20 of materials and five minutes work.

▲embedding-shape a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> but jacks for MIDI is unfair, I think.

Feels like studio setups are personal and individual enough that you can't say it's fair or unfair for someone else to care about specific features. Everything I own, including my own modular synth, has MIDI DIN ports on them, so I too look for that in new gear, but friend of mine too don't use MIDI for anything, obviously he doesn't look for that :)

▲EmX_3000 a day ago | parent [-]

USB MIDI seems tempting, you can send a giant virtual MIDI cable snake down one wire, but the connector issue rears its head again. It'd be cool if there was a more robust standard for USB connectors. I bet industry, the military, scientists, professional audio people etc. would all love such a thing.

▲brudgers a day ago | parent [-]

USB Midi requires a host. So it kinda kills any Dawless vibe.

▲EmX_3000 a day ago | parent [-]

My newish MPC is a host and while it offers a lot of added functions over old MPCs, it works nearly identically for the MIDI sequencing workflow. In the old days I had an MPC 2000 and then 2000XL, I still own both. The newer MPC is both much cheaper, but it also allows me to get as many ins and outs as I can fill my rack and desk up with and more, all at once. You had to pay a lot extra to get the MPC3000 with 2 ins and 4 outs (IIRC), like $4-5k.

They really nailed it by offering more than the old MPCs but making it all completely optional to use, and keeping nearly the same workflow as the old ones. Only thing new MPCs can't do is bulk SYSEX dumps and vomits, I still keep an old Yamaha portable unit for that (runs on a bunch of AAs) with a modern USB floppy converter replacing the drive.

▲brudgers a day ago | parent [-]

I agree about the MPC...I have a Force (because it was cheaper than a used MPC One and more powerful).

But when I don't feel like that paradigm, USB MIdi is not very useful (and of course an MPC can still work with TRS/DIN).

When I want lots of ins and outs, I use a MOTU MIDI Timepiece AV (they're not much more than a decent USB hub and can filter and route and do all sorts of clocking).

▲hdb2 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> but jacks for MIDI is unfair

not the person you're replying to, but -

I would be ok w/ the 1/8" jacks if there weren't TWO STANDARDS to keep up with. madness!

▲xhevahir a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It looks cheap because it is cheap—something like $60 US. As for understanding the market, they appear to be doing an okay job of it; lots of people are buying three or more of these.

▲UncleOxidant a day ago | parent [-]

> It looks cheap because it is cheap—something like $60 US

I just got one for $48 on aliexpress.

▲tartoran a day ago | parent [-]

Are you in the US? How much did it come to including shipping and taxes?

▲UncleOxidant a day ago | parent [-]

Yes. $49.44 was the total price including shipping.

▲tartoran a day ago | parent [-]

That's really a good price. Thanks

▲alexjplant a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> toy-grade

This thing is absolutely worth the $$$ once you install Sloop on it but I regret having bought one only because I'm getting way more mileage out of using a small game pad to drive the iOS port of Dirtywave M8 (and am probably going to buy a hardware unit when they restock). Personally I enjoy the tracker workflow and chopping samples infinitely more than doing the sequencer thing on a tiny screen but I can't argue that this unit is very powerful for how cheap it is.

▲EmX_3000 a day ago | parent | next [-]

I bought a Polyend Tracker and it also has a toy-grade build. I love the instrument itself, they just open-sourced the whole software stack as it's going discontinued. But the device itself is cheap and the rubbery coating on the top panel is already starting to wear under the knob where I rest my hand. I want to build a custom enclosure that has a tilted screen, real MIDI ports, and a wooden top with a palm rest when the plastic eventually gives out or gets too gross, quite a few people have done custom enclosures even with internal batteries already.

But yeah the cheapness is an issue. Even older entry-grade gear, while often entirely plastic, is much more robust and with real ports, they often have one of those little plastic rakes that retains your power cable too. A three cent addition I'm sure but one which is great to have.

I already have some groove boxes, what does this one bring to the table? Every groove box is annoying in its own way even the really good ones. I have yet to find something that does it all better than the good old MPC. I need a MIDI event list editor, very very few grooveboxes offer this. Only Emu/Ensoniq, Akai and Yamaha's did. Akai still offers it but I don't think their newer mini-MPC has this.

▲alexjplant a day ago | parent | next [-]

Buy an old Thinkpad, put NixOS + Renoise on it (without a browser and with a very primitive WM), and build a QMK/Vial keyboard with encoders. It'll cost you $200 and get you everything it sounds like you want.

▲SmirkingRevenge a day ago | parent | prev [-]

That's the tracker mini I take it? I have the Tracker+ and it's build quality is quite solid w/ an aluminum front panel. I really wish it had a battery though.

▲EmX_3000 7 hours ago | parent [-]

Nope, Polyend Tracker, first version.

▲rrix2 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I've been using my M8 and the FM-1 together, they make a good combo.

▲SmirkingRevenge a day ago | parent | prev [-]

M8 is really addicting and probably the most engaging little music device I've ever had. Definitely not toy-grade in build and it's one of the most capable hardware devices out there in it's price range too. It punches way above it's weight

▲Elfener a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> It has a fan, that's not good at all.

I think that's actually the built-in speaker?

▲Zetaphor a day ago | parent [-]

Correct, it does not have a fan

▲EmX_3000 a day ago | parent [-]

That's a relief. The only thing I have in my studio with a fan is my ancient Roland Virtual Studio which I love and which still can not be replaced by anything newer because of the lack of full MIDI control over all features.

▲brudgers a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It has a speaker not a fan.

It has audio out and Midi over USB.

It has Blutooth Midi…use it as a controller. And it has Bluetooth audio…use it as a speaker…for example you can play a synth on you iPhone and monitor the output with an FM-1.

The battery lasts a reasonable time and it can be powered by USB…you don’t need a special wall-wart (or you can stay unplugged with an ordinary power bank).

In terms of build, I’d say its about as roadworthy as a Volca. At worst it’s no more fiddly. And the display is much much less cryptic.

▲ghostly_s a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It has exactly one Midi port because it is a cheap device. You're in a tiny minority who would prefer changing batteries to plugging in a charging cable. And it absolutely does not have a fan.

▲jimmyjazz14 a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I mean its basically meant to be a toy and it competition are things like the Korg Volca series, the primary factor in that market is price and mvave clearly hit it out of the park on this one when it come to price-to-value (for people that are into small toy-like synths).