Remix.run Logo
▲ welferkj 2 days ago

How does a declining population where one worker has to support multiple retirees solve any of that, though? All these degrowth arguments fail to address the age pyramid question, which is the fundamental reason economists are warning against population decline.

Or are you proposing we make sure all age groups degrow at the same rate? Because that's the one way to make population decline actually work for us (for some values of "us").

▲giva 2 days ago | parent | next [-]

Well, aging people should use their accumulated wealth to pay for their support. This is how a defined contribution retirement system should work.

▲welferkj a day ago | parent [-]

What is this "should" you're talking about now? How does it affect the millions of retirees who paid into the current system before you decided "should" comes into it?

You're basically proposing the final age re-pyramiding solution by other means.

▲hdhxbsbsbshs 2 days ago | parent | prev [-]

It’s typical leftist pseudo-rebellion. Lofty words, with just enough of an argument to convince the average college student that it’s a good idea.

Their only practical goal is to give the government more power and to force you to pay more taxes. Don’t try to find any more rationality in it than that.

▲welferkj a day ago | parent [-]

I mean, the base argument that people should be allowed to choose whether or not to reproduce makes sense. They utterly fail on the normative judgement of whether a society where people are systematically choosing not to is a good thing, as well as the predictive judgement of what it would take to change that.