| ▲ | stephen_cagle 6 hours ago | |
Thank you for the reading list! I appreciate it. Since you seem to be a real fan of the series and enjoy it, I will take your advice and read a future one at some point. But I would be curious what your feelings on a re-read of book 1 and 2 would be? I was just completely floored by the change in character that I saw in book 2. I felt like the book started with a normal, slightly above average, inquisitive character, who is handling new (and often mundane) challenges in his life one item (trading stand) at a time. And book 2 just retconed him into a gigachad who seemed to have none of the uncertain or hesitant nature of the book 1 character. | ||
| ▲ | shagie 5 hours ago | parent [-] | |
I'd contend that his insecurities were about the culture that he found himself in... which incidentally is an important point. From book 6:
This is timestamped as 2372.. book 2 is 2352.I don't see it as him being insecure about himself as such. He's as much of a chad as any physically fit 19-year-old is... He's still as culturally insecure at 20 as he is when he's 40 - trying to figure out how he fits in as a spacer who wasn't born to a spacer family. So how does one handle the cultural insecurities at different points in one's life? At 20? At 40? nearly 50? Book 5 gets a bit into the difference between the expectations of a planet (or station) life and that of a spacer and the stress there on relationships (and how they can work). From the start of In Ashes Born this is stated quite clearly when talking to a therapist:
I'd contend that the overall arch of Ishmael's story is about seeking to be part of a family and with various people helping him learn that along the way. | ||