Remix.run Logo
▲ brandonpelfrey a day ago

It’s strange to me seeing multiple talk about how Terry’s viewpoint has evolved or not as a response to this post. He didn’t write this.

▲jacquesm a day ago | parent [-]

He did attach his name to it by posting it. I'd imagine if he disagreed strongly he wouldn't do that, or he would at least add a footnote.

What you could argue though is that he is muddying the waters with all these guest posts on a domain that is as personal as it gets. I appreciate he's trying to be the 'Carlos Santana of mathematics' by sharing the spotlight but it might be good to highlight the distance a bit more, for instance by adding his own views.

▲isotypic a day ago | parent | next [-]

Well, you're wrong, given how many of the guest posts featured by Tao are inherently contradictory and so it would be strange for him to be personally endorsing each one! He also posts his own views elsewhere: see https://teorth.github.io/tao-web/ai-views.html.

The obvious goal is to highlight differing attitudes within the mathematics community so the mathematics community can have a dialogue and see what other people are thinking. Luckily, most mathematicians seem to be able to actually read and understand not all posts are from Tao. It is unfortunate it seems many people on this site cannot.

▲jacquesm a day ago | parent [-]

Posting something on a domain with your name attached to it is an endorsement of sorts. You can argue with that all you want but that's just how it works. Having a dialogue happens on neutral ground and Tao's blog is not neutral ground, even if that might be his intention.

▲gpm a day ago | parent | prev [-]

If he thought it was fundamentally an unreasonable position he probably wouldn't do that. But he seems to be running his blog as something of an open(ish) forum for AI commentary. I suspect if he thinks it's a reasonable position that happens to be entirely incorrect he still would post it...

▲jacquesm a day ago | parent [-]

I believe you, but without a stated policy that is speculative. To me it is indistinguishable from curated guest posts.

▲gpm a day ago | parent [-]

I don't have such a stated policy... I do have that he both

1. Signed an open letter https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/11/a-severe-misalignm...

2. Posted a guest post about why they didn't sign said open letter https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/17/why-i-didnt-sign-t...

▲jacquesm a day ago | parent [-]

Good example, thank you. Position adjusted.