Remix.run Logo
▲ pimeys 4 hours ago

Finland has a lot of people who care about forest and Finland needs to pay fines for EU if they don't have enough forest to suck CO2 from the air.

Google cut corners here, and didn't ask for the needed permissions. And the prime minister doesn't want to show his conversation with Google regarding this.

People are really pissed.

Edit: and the electricity prices are going up due to these data centers. And the profits from them don't stay in Finland, but go to American corporations. There should be Finnish data centers owned by Finns instead of having Google to take the cheap electricity and taking profits out.

▲mtlmtlmtlmtl 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Same thing with data centres in Norway. We're planning to waste heaps of our renewable energy on generating profits for a small cabal of assholes in SV. For what? Luckily there's been more political pushback against it here recently, but it's so tame. Just for once I'd like to see some conviction. Pause all ongoing constructions, and launch corruption probes into all the local politicians that pushed this stuff through. I bet there's lots of corruption there. On a national level, we don't have corruption on anything near the systemic scale you see in the US. Some bad apples, and lots of mole hills made into mountains by the press, but nothing like the US where it seems like most of congress is pretty much openly corrupt.

Local politicians though? Oh boy. Seems like every time there's some ongoing project in a smaller municipality involving commercial exploitation of natural resources(like undeveloped land, minerals, hydropower capacity, etc) there's a mayor and/or municipal council members who profit from it financially or otherwise. They have shares/board seats in a holding company owning the land, local contractors, etc. Seems like this is very widespread, and rarely leads to serious consequences, and even when it does, it happens so late that the project is already built, or so far underway it doesn't get stopped. Shit pisses me off.

I'm sure data centres are no different. Because I can't imagine a cost-benefit analysis of them that makes any sense from the point of view of the local community.

▲WarmWash 13 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

>generating profits for a small cabal of assholes in SV.

People say that, but users are the ones capturing most if not almost all of the profit.

You don't cut Anthropic a check every time a new user signs up on your platform. You pay them a small slice of the revenue that their models generate for you.

▲pimeys 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Like... the town where the Google datacenter goes gets like some paved bike road from Google who "takes care of the community". Price tag around the profits of less than an hour of the GPU time in that datacenter.

An article in Finnish: https://www.uusijuttu.fi/juttu/sCcu9YiY-mjF4UD1O-b66ec

▲Avicebron 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Well if it's any consolation, the profits from the datacenters go to a handful of Americans. People are just as pissed about them here.

▲bluecalm an hour ago | parent | next [-]

You know those companies are publicly owned and big % of American public owns shares in them? Additionally Google employs some 100k people in US and almost as many in Europe. Those are mostly very good jobs as well.

The whole anti-datacenters sentiments is stupid but "profits go to a handful of Americans" is just pants of fire kind of take.

▲WarmWash 9 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

The actual value goes to the people who are boosting their productivity with AI.

If you are paying $200/mo and getting $10,000 of value from it, then you are capturing 98% of the value.

People seem to inherently understand this, while consciously being unaware of it.

▲dzhiurgis 7 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Mid-terms are almost here and left wing anti-DC propaganda bots are scrambling.

I'm sure you too noticed it too when Yandex datacenters went down so did all the anti-datacenter posts too.

▲andai 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

You reminded me of something. I heard in the Czech Republic when communism ended, the state owned industries became owned by the public. Every citizen received a share.

I wonder if we're going to need something similar when AI nukes the economy.

▲jabron 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

It worked that way in Russia too. Some people managed to quickly consolidate those shares by exploiting the economic hardship of the people caused by the fall of the USSR by hoovering up those shares for Kopecks on the Rubel, and that's where the current day oligarchy was formed.

▲SoftTalker 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Same thing would happen. There'd be signs on every street light pole "Sell your AI shares. CASH PAID TODAY!!"

▲453yuh46 7 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

No. Nothing to do with current criminal oligarchs, that are consolidating businesses by robbing owners of companies by overtaking their business with force and access to state and Putin. Like it was with conflict with division of Wildberies, when owner had to cooperate with Chechen mafia so her ex-husband would not have robbed her of her business.

Hodorkovsky became oligarch, because he represented Western investors in very profitable oil industry, that is basically what Russia was able to offer to the world, as most of factories from Soviet times were not usable in market economy - nobody wanted what they produced. That is the reason why many people were having hardships in 1990ies, because they had no job and no money to exist. Only in times of Putin Russia had influx of foreign money from oil and gas, which was redistributed to other people as well. But everything is fleeting in Russia.

▲tdeck 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Reminds me of this somewhat related video that describes the process of selling off state industries in East Germany

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cdrSiIoWm7U&pp=ygUMZ2RyIHRyZXV...

▲pimeys 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

A bottle of vodka for your shares, comrade. Etc...

▲lo_zamoyski 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The transition from communism to capitalism was hardly as rosy as people in the West like to think.

Of course, how this unfolded varied. For example, unlike the chaotic Russian privatization that created a class of oligarchs, the transition in places like Poland favored a network of well-placed insiders, a highly structured network of intelligence officers (military, civilian), state managers, and flexible communist party elites, who - by controlling information, intelligence networks, and the liquidation apparatus - effectively laundered their authoritarian political privileges into financial dominance.

▲jacquesm 2 hours ago | parent [-]

It's incredible that none of this stuff was repossessed.

▲pimeys an hour ago | parent [-]

Yes. Should also cover what happened in East Germany when the wall went down. And people are now somehow surprised when everybody's kind of pissed outside of the few big cities.

▲jacquesm an hour ago | parent [-]

There was a West Berlin bunch of real estate tycoons that got wind the wall was about to fall and they went across and started buying property left, right and center. They made billions on that, effectively owning the heart of Berlin post unification.

Funny story: I once got arrested at Checkpoint Charlie :)

▲pimeys 31 minutes ago | parent [-]

Here some pics from those empty skyscrapers that are completely missing all the walls and the scaffolding's been gathering rust for years. And all the court cases for the people who bought the "luxury apartments" that never realized.

I'm always surprised that the topography of terror exhibition in Berlin misses this part of the German history. Nazi's and communists are presented, but the robber barons who bought all the real estate don't get a presentation.

▲paimapi 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Right, I think if we all had the same transparency, regulatory oversight, and involved electorate, we'd be as concerned with the other massive logging projects around the world.

I'm glad this one is getting attention, though. May the Finnish people show us how we can get it right.

▲pimeys 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Oh the logging projects also get a LOT of attention. It's just that the current government is center-right / far right, and they just let the logging to continue no matter the sanctions from the EU.

There are a lot of people who are against this, and protest against this. Looking at the polls, seems that it will change in the next elections, like a lot.

▲dzhiurgis 9 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> and the electricity prices are going up due to these data centers

Got source for this? My impression is that base loads decrease power prices. Has something changed?

▲TheMagicHorsey 7 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is the kind of "paperwork maximal" nonsense that is killing Europe.

Google DID apply for the right permissions, and they even had a consultant on the ground with years of experience who was supposed to navigate these complexities ... and even WITH all that, you get the result of idiots saying "Google BYPASSED OUR LAWS!!!!!"

Sit in the shoes of a Google lawyer trying to navigate all of this nonsense. Why is there not one government entity telling Google, okay, you need to do XYZ to do this. Instead, they got the ok from several Finnish agencies to go ahead. And then, even as a surprise to the exiting Finnish government agencies they were working with, yet ANOTHER agency shows up and says OH YOU DIDNT DO ABCDEFGHIJK steps.

You people are just ridiculous.

▲pimeys 4 minutes ago | parent [-]

Because the prime minister has been running a government that is disliked from all directions. Because the economy has been going down and hard. Because the unemployment rates are the highest in EU.

And now he can shake hands with Google executives in a public photo.

People still live in the old world that thinks that doing business with the American corporations is somehow beneficial, especially with data centers. But the country should focus on building their own data centers, providing GPUs for smaller companies and providing cheap DeepSeek for Europeans instead of giving access to Google.

▲salt-thrower 16 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]