Remix.run Logo
▲ xmcp123 3 hours ago

I have been writing bots and scrapers for almost 20 years.

Not once have I had someone I work for in this capacity even ask about robots.txt

▲xena an hour ago | parent | next [-]

How much would I have to pay you for you to change careers permanently?

▲kazinator an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

robots.txt can used as a reward mechanism. If an automated visitor that we would normally block begins by accessing robots.txt that's a good sign and we give that a plus score or whatever. If subsequent accesses from that visitor comply with robots.txt, we let them continue (perhaps with some rate checks).

Conversely, if an obviously automated visitor does not fetch robots.txt, that can be an instant ban, kind of like a reverse honey pot, if you will.

So it can have some nonzero value in the overall context; it's just silly to think of it as a blocking mechanism.

In short, robots.txt documents what access is allowed; it states the policy. Enforcing it the job of something else.

Someone you work for in this capacity shouldn't ask about robots.txt because that's the sort of detail for which they have you to deal with.

▲salawat 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

You are part of the problem, sounds like.

▲appplication 2 hours ago | parent [-]

This implies the solution is every actor in the world willfully complying which doesn’t sound very realistic if you ask me.

Similar to saying world hunger would be solved in everyone who could donated $100 to those in need. Sure it may be true but foot stomping about why isn’t it organically happening is missing the point.

▲gherkinnn an hour ago | parent [-]

There is a clear difference between the global issue of famine and actively choosing to work for an arsehole corp.

▲appplication an hour ago | parent [-]

The problem itself does not matter. If the nature of any solution relies on willful global compliance, it’s not going to be very effective at whatever it’s trying to solve.

▲otterley 10 minutes ago | parent [-]

So, what’s your proposed solution?