Remix.run Logo
▲ Is MCP becoming the common foundation of smart, decentralised search?(contextetech.com)
12 points by contextetech 2 hours ago | 9 comments
▲randomblock1 43 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

No, because HTTP already is. You can't have every MCP added. Every harness has a search tool, so just fetch data as needed. MCP isn't for search, it's for interacting. Sometimes that's search but mostly not.

▲aerzen 23 minutes ago | parent [-]

Pi doesn't have a search tool. I think of web search as an interaction with a search engine. So it makes perfect sense to use MCP.

(although i don't, i have a CLI)

▲brap 17 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

For web services, what is the point of MCP or even a skill when modern agents can just find API docs on their own and use it?

I think in this day and age agents no longer need official 3P integrations, they can just use whatever API is already available (and in some cases even the UI).

▲dingaling911 6 minutes ago | parent [-]

Figuring out the quirks of each api is a waste in tokens but I agree once you decide on a specific integration it makes sense to use an api.

Still, mcp means you don’t need to figure out the quirks.

Net, I think mcp is extremely good for resource constrained circumstances. I add mcp servers to many of my own applications and it’s an automatic productivity boost.

As a bonus, when I want to automate the integration I literally make my automations use mcp.

▲porori 11 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Decentralised search sounds weird to me. Searching always needs a centralised collection.

▲hobofan an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Three things still have to be built, server by server

> citation

Nope, as long as the MCP server exposes enough metadata to be cited (mostly trivial), citation is a job of the client/LLM.

> trust

Also just a function of the client. The server can't aid here at all as it's inherently untrustworthy in the system.

> measurement

Maybe. Though it's debatable how much measurement _each_ server needs, and whether that actually gives meaningful insight to optimize. This might as well be measured outside of the servers, in the client/a centralized logging system that also sees surrounding context.

▲troupo an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

As always, the answer to an article whose title is a yes/no question: no

▲usernametaken29 14 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

No

▲gjvc 13 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

no