Remix.run Logo
▲ danpalmer 4 hours ago

I sort of agree, but I can see their point. The author seems concerned that they strongly disagree with Blow, and have a piece of his writing that, if it echoes his world view, might end in a way they don't support, and they haven't got to the end yet.

I'm personally less concerned. Partly because I attribute Blow's social opinions to naivety and ignorance rather than malice – e.g. I think he holds misogynistic views not because he is trying to be misogynistic, but because he's naive about the systemic bias in society, a criticism that can be levelled at many people.

But otherwise, I'm less concerned about Order of the Sinking Star because he has said in interviews that the story is supposed to be interesting to a wide audience and not intended to be based on his world view in any way. The Witness also wasn't some right wing think piece, it was just pretentious.

I get why a journalist would be concerned, but I think they're being overly cautious.

▲ehnto 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

There is a place for stories we don't agree with or that illustrate aspects of our world we might not be happy about, and the creator isn't necessarily complicit just for telling it. I feel we shouldn't hit the writers of those stories for telling them, as not everyone tells a story because they personally support it's message or the status quo it illustrates.

I also think the enlightened have a habit of underestimating how much of an audience the status quo has, and I think that's an ignorance of its own.

And because it's the internet I feel the need to subtext that this is by no means a supportive comment toward Blows personal beliefs. I don't know what they are!

▲latexr 3 hours ago | parent [-]

> Blows personal beliefs. I don't know what they are!

From his tweets and streams I learned that he believes Trump is by far (his characterisation) the best president of his life time, and that he makes fallacious arguments such as defending a belief in God because (paraphrasing) “many physicists believe in it” (appeal to authority).

I can’t tell you much more because I personally got tired of what I saw first hand and decided I shouldn’t spend my time on it. Things like the COVID conspiracies mentioned in the article are not something I can personally attest to.

For better and worse there is a cult of personality around Blow. He puts his views out there and is constantly on stream, all of which is his choice. For sure it’ll lead to many more sales of the game from the fans, but it also opens the door to criticism. He’s very aggressive in sharing his opinion so there shouldn’t be any surprise there is pushback.

Should that affect your purchase of the game? Only you can answer that. I can’t fault people for deciding to not monetarily support those whose beliefs harm their lives, and it seems worth considering that designers responsible for the game have disavowed the creator to the point they’ll be donating their part of the proceeds.

▲slopinthebag 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

what are his misogynistic views? the only thing i saw that people might take offence to was that he voted for trump, but he didn't seem like he was particularly happy to do so.

▲bowsamic 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

He said women are less interested in programming than men

▲slopinthebag an hour ago | parent [-]

if i said men are less interested in teaching would that be misandrist? genuine question

▲bowsamic an hour ago | parent [-]

No, but I agree with Jon Blow

▲latexr 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> he voted for trump, but he didn't seem like he was particularly happy to do so.

What makes you say that? He called him by far the best president of his life time. Seems perfectly happy to me.

https://x.com/Jonathan_Blow/status/1887599339037663629#m

https://xxcancel.com/Jonathan_Blow/status/188759933903766362...

▲slopinthebag an hour ago | parent [-]

tbf i didnt see that and was going by this tweet

https://x.com/Jonathan_Blow/status/1939982295936782396

i still cant quite get a read tbh. a lot of people were pro trump based on 2016-2020 which was a very different trump compared to today. id be curious his thoughts on today, because banana republic indeed.

▲boxed 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[flagged]

▲Kudos 3 hours ago | parent [-]

What nuance are you referring to?