Remix.run Logo
▲ gyomu 4 hours ago

If China is to the 21st century what the US were to the 20th century - economically, scientifically, industrially - what should I do as a US citizen working in tech, besides signing up my kids and myself for Chinese classes?

▲AnotherGoodName 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I'm quite lucky in that i have the right to live and work in America, Australia, New Zealand, UK and the EU. I've also thought about this a lot as i near retirement (working in tech in the USA atm, it's been a fun ride but definitely time to think about options).

Australians don't like to acknowledge it, i guess to avoid being flooded since house prices are high, but it's the easiest pick by far. A western nation which rises as China rises due to sheer resource wealth and stable government.

Currently it's already >3x the median wealth per capita of the USA. Slightly lower on average but medians the real way to judge for the typical (non-0.01%) person.

Exports more than it imports.

Government revenues have been far ahead of spending for the past few years. Can you believe that?! A western government not just going into ever increasing government debt!

An extraordinary rollout of solar and batteries (dwarfing China's attempts at solar on a per capita basis) to the point where you can sign up to plans where power is free during peak daylight hours and the government will pay you $3k to install a home battery to store that free power.

Basically no tariffs so you can buy an electric car for USD$15k. Which goes well with the above point.

I look at the USA, UK and EU and people seem to have given up trying to vote in a better government? They don't seem to care about importing more than exporting or government spending exceeding revenue as election issues worth voting on?

▲brabel an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I have EU, Australian and Brazilian passports, so I could live in even more countries including the Mercosul region. I actually live in the EU because of its culture, food, more advanced startup scene and tech companies. Living quality is very similar here and in Australia, what makes the difference is whether you prefer to avoid too cold or too hot weather. Swedens finances are actually better than Australia s as far as I know.

I couldn’t imagine a better place to live than Northern Europe, but Australia is a close second for me. Been to China, Japan, Canada, the US and I think parts of those countries are also really nice to live, just not a good match for me culturally.

Now South America is a different story. If you like good weather and a festive atmosphere it’s actually the best place to live, just don’t expect to have money or to live in a functioning state where services work!

▲Qazpqaz an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I feel like government is on easy mode if you have a huge amount of natural resources vs your size. See Norway too.

Not saying these countries don't do good things too, but a lot of bad things compound when the government has to balance its books.

▲samudrijan 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The Biden admin passed the chips act along w the infrastructure bill. Too bad about their support for genocide and endless military spending.

Hard to say what good the Trump admin is doing except exposing the rot in right wing “governance.”

▲gkanai 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

As someone who lived in China for 5 years pre-pandemic, it's fine to visit China, enjoy the cuisine, enjoy the culture. Learn the language, all good.

But living full time in China and competing with Chinese in China as a non Chinese person- that's not something you want to do.

▲ElProlactin an hour ago | parent | next [-]

> But living full time in China and competing with Chinese in China...

Even countless Chinese in China don't want to do this.

▲asanineassasin 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]

▲rr808 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

That's the problem right. Learning Chinese wont help you, China is a closed shop, no immigrants, no sharing work with anyone outside the country, no employing people outside China, no cooperation with any other country really; just keep buying their stuff.

▲brabel 37 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Are you nuts or just misinformed? China is investing everywhere. Africa, south America, Russia, EU. And they do have immigrants, as a Western person it’s actually quite easy to move there to study or work. Lots of Europeans I know have studied and worked in China and Taiwan.

▲soohamr 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

China is not a isolationist, monoethnic economy with draconian restrictions on its commerce and immigration. You are plainly wrong, uneducated and defeatist in your take. I'm a non-Chinese person who has lived and worked there for a decade.

China welcomes all skilled foreign talent to come work and take residence in the country with open arms. The process to live and work in China is open and transparent as in any other major Asian economy: first find a job there and second, apply for the visa. You can even work for a major Chinese multinational outside of China, provided that they aren't blacklisted like ZTE by the US government.

Don't enter with the expectation to naturalize and you will find you can do more than you think: go work for Baidu in Beijing, study in Fudan University as a student, or start your own business. Whatever you feel like mostly. Understand that you are on a visa and adjust your conduct like any immigrant in any western country understands.

Learning Chinese has amazing utility but most expatriates can get by without knowing a lick of it, my own family is living proof of this. Any multinational hiring a foreign talent will also hire translators for said talent. In day to day life there is no shortage of people in the city who can speak english, for the rest there are LLM's and translation apps. The Chinese community is behind on truly understanding life from the immigrant's perspective but it is adapting positively.

The most common objection from outsiders is the restricted access to global services like Google, Facebook, OpenAI, the easiest remedy for that is to just use a VPN. You can order a latte from Starbucks down the road in the meantime - or Luckin coffee if you want a better option.

A lot of the fear is unfounded. The local police station is not going to arrest you for accessing the outside world. You aren't going to lose a "social credit score" for being late to work, cutting a line or being obnoxious in public, the scoring system exists but AFAIK it serves as a tool in extreme scenarios, but AFAIK most foreigners don't get one.

Finally, coming back to intentionality of the restriction - most restrictions that irk outsiders are codified and enacted to protect domestic business and individual interests. Reasonable to heavy restrictions on curtailed big American conglomerates and services allowed for amazing domestic alternatives like TikTok/Douyin, BYD, Deepseek to flourish. Companies which provided keystone infrastructure the economy - like Visa - were deemed too critical to allow for a strangle-hold and regulated, for these acted as a foreign tax on every domestic transaction, thus Alipay and Unionpay were born.

▲ElProlactin 42 minutes ago | parent [-]

> China welcomes all skilled foreign talent to come work and take residence in the country with open arms.

This just isn't true. There's a K visa for young STEM professionals, which is about a year old. It's a bit more flexible for this very narrow group, otherwise you need a Z visa and work permit. You need a job first before the provincial labor authorities will approve a work permit. There's a points system, salary requirements and age cap.

There's no practical path to permanent residence in China. The Chinese "green card" equivalent has been issued to under 15,000 people since 2004. Even under Trump, the US issues about 10x more green cards in a single year than China has in two decades.

The numbers don't lie: in a country of over a billion people, there are well under 1 million foreign workers. There's a massive problem with youth underemployment and unemployment and net migration has been negative for 75+ years.

▲JimTheMan 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I mean, have you worked with the Chinese? They're not like that at all.

They love money so much, you could swear they're American!

▲minraws 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Everyone loves money but socially and culturally China is a lot more closed compared to US, much more so than what people are used to atleast.

US was arguably the most open country on the planet in terms of acceptance of ideas and cultural diversity especially in 20th century.

But I also don't think people need to be very worried but still we haven't had monocultures on the top or close to the top of power hierarchy for several decades so it's going to be uncomfortable for a lot of people.

For instance China is heavily censorious of LGBTQ and very likely against the Idea they haven't banned it outright yet thankfully. But then again lots of countries are in a similar boat.

But the biggest difference is China can easily back slide without possiblity of return on any metric because it's not a democracy.

▲seanmcdirmid 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

China has a pretty vibrant LGBTQ scene, even Shenzhen was known as comrade city in the 90s. China is at the same time very closed and very open. It’s hard to describe.

I had lots of friends when I lived in Beijing who were gay, the gay bars weren’t underground and my gay coworkers weren’t in the closest, for L/girls it was even more out in the open (especially at the art schools). If you haven’t lived in China I guess you wouldn’t have a clue.

▲minraws 23 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

I went to China recently it felt different, the recent govt stance seem a lot more against the idea and the ones before which was my point, China in the 90s was a very different country from the China of today, then again I haven't been there then.

Again it's hard to say where it's open or where it's closed, they seem to be back sliding in very weird ways. I am not part of the LGBTQ community so I can't say for certain how bad it is, so I won't comment further but UN & human rights watch has been citing increasing censoring of LGBT representation and open-ness in China in recent times.

The biggest concern with China is lack of democratic freedom means as long as it's not bad enough to revolt the country can back slide pretty easily on many metrics with complete silence, no protests etc.

[1]: https://www.hrw.org/news/2026/06/25/china-social-media-films...

▲ 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲bruce511 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

"Was" being the operative word there. It's been a long time since new (foreign) ideas were accepted, and the resistance to cultural change has been ever present.

American culture is capitalism, and that isn't changing, just getting more extreme. Equally American culture is "white European" and the resistance to change there (racially and culturally) is woven into US history.

▲0dayz 2 hours ago | parent [-]

You're describing pretty much any bug nation that has enormous economic wealth.

▲singingtoday 2 hours ago | parent [-]

What does "bug" mean in this context? I apologize if this is an acronym or jargon I should know.

*Edit it's a typo. You meant big.

▲ylxdzsw 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Probably get a PR in Hong Kong and hope to be automatically "promoted" to Chinese in 20 years?

▲hgoel an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I get the intention, but I feel it may be a particularly extreme comparison, since the US being what it was to the 20th century involved two world wars, decolonization, the cold war, and decades of reconstruction.

Currently, even if China pulls ahead, it doesn't have to mean things getting worse in the US. Contrary to what the current government seems to believe, growth is not necessarily zero sum. Despite Americans' perception of Europe, they too remain competitive in various domains of research. Similarly with, say, Japan.

▲js8 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The UK was still doing quite well after the Suez crisis, but the oil shock and thatcherism was when deindustrialization really hit. Try to prevent that.

▲ 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲Danox 41 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Chinese and Spanish…

▲ 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲satvikpendem 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Move there, not sure taking language classes would help if you're still staying here.

▲soohamr an hour ago | parent | next [-]

You don't need to speak Chinese to live in big cities.

▲Danox 35 minutes ago | parent [-]

You need to speak the language…

▲seanmcdirmid 32 minutes ago | parent [-]

You can totally get by on survival phrases. Many of my fellow foreign coworkers in Beijing could barely speak a few phrases and they did fine. Today it’s even easier than it was 20 years ago.

▲teaearlgraycold 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Sounds like a horrible idea. You don't need to be in the #1 fastest growing country to have a good life and Asian work culture seems miserable.

▲satvikpendem an hour ago | parent [-]

Well that's what the parent seems to want, since they're the one asking, not me.

▲k12sosse 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Move to a cabin in the woodlands and teach them how to work on engines, and animal husbandry.

▲mapontosevenths 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Another programmer who played Stardew Valley one too many times, I see.

▲y-curious 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Every tech worker seems to have a Ted Kaczynski streak lol

▲xqcgrek2 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Neither. Align yourself with the AI that will be running the show and hope it adequately feeds you.

▲bilbo0s 3 hours ago | parent [-]

This is the real answer.

But noone is gonna want to hear it.

▲verdverm 3 hours ago | parent [-]

That American Ai companies have convinced so many this is a foregone conclusion is the defeatism they are after. We can choose a different future