Over in the "AI is not a tool" post there's this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50063732

Which says that it's a tool for querying and summarization, but not a tool for reading or writing, because it helps you to do something different from those.

(Yes I know, don't cross the streams. I just thought it was a shame for this nice distinction to languish over there when you need it over here.)

Is lint a tool? If so, what's wrong with treating Claude as an ungodly-effective lint? You don't have to one-shot everything, or anything at all. You can ask for as much help or as little help as you need.

Another way to look at it: when I'm using Claude to write application code, I'm engaging with the machine and the work product in a different way. I'm not "programming" anymore, so OK, maybe it's reasonable to say Claude isn't a programming tool. Instead, I'm doing something new, something that perhaps we don't have a verb for yet. Whatever that verb is, Claude is a tool for it.