> put enforceable guardrails on the definition

This is the issue!

Without objective, verifiable criteria, the rules cannot be enforced. Rules without enforcement rely on the strength of community norms, which we don’t have in this case.

All you’re going to do is end up banning obviously vibe coded crap. If that’s what they mean, say it.

In spite of the positive reaction, this IS a bad policy because it isn’t enforceable.

Keep thinking - we need guidelines that focus on our needs and goals, not the basic mechanics of code creation.