Remix.run Logo
▲ pks016 6 hours ago

> But it also sucks when mathematicians, who are considered experts on a particular problem, refuse to engage with breakthrough results about that problem.

It might be a shock for you but they are very few in numbers. Most of researchers I know are always busy with something. They cannot just drop other responsibilities for something like this. They will take their own time getting through the proofs (if they want to).

> That seems like a much healthier attitude towards these new results.

Another thing to consider is not all mathematicians are from US or with good funding. The PI or graduate students cannot afford to pay 200/month.

▲oliculipolicula 6 hours ago | parent [-]

I think the role of specific _human_ mathematicians at OpenAI should not be understated.

TFA was about a niche topic that OpenAI doesn't have in-house expertise in.

Otoh Aaronson is the co-author on Lijie Chen's (reasoning lead at OAI) top cited paper. OAI have deployed their resources more effectively against UGC that some of their staff are already familiar with

https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=T_OhvOsAAAAJ

https://finance.biggo.com/news/B0eMxZsBy4YEFZDUVPWh

▲pks016 6 hours ago | parent [-]

That's true. OpenAI has some of the best talents. In my experience, domain experts get the most benefits from the models. They can work much faster, catch false positives, and stir the model in right direction.

I wish they take a bit of more time to communicate the findings effectively.

▲steinwinde 41 minutes ago | parent [-]

> I wish they take a bit of more time

There are good reasons not to delay publishing at all:

> They should release all their results immediately. (Imagine working on one of the problems they already solved.)

This is the most popular answer to a question regarding AI advisory group and immediate access on a popular website for professional mathematicians: https://mathoverflow.net/a/515442/473286

The whole debate regarding the behaviour of OpenAI is a red herring. Mathematics need to redefine their profession and how they work (like us software developers too). There are very good reasons to believe mathematics has an important role to play. If they could just stop talking about OpenAI and get back to work - they are very much needed, in particular now!