If anything in a world with agents, these TCC dialogs just need to have an "allow once", just like Location Services has on iOS, and just like most harnesses have, a la "Do you want to allow $AGENT to run the following command?" A. Yes. B. Yes and don't ask for $command, C. No but instead just asking "Do you want to allow Claude Desktop access to files and folders on your Desktop?" A. Once. B. Always C. No

I think the issue comes in with terminal emulators and CLI harnesses. TCC permissions are inherited from the "responsible" process, so if you grant Terminal.app or ghostty.app FDA, you've granted zsh or bash or python or any goddamned thing you can run in a shell FDA.

It is! The directory grant is once and the sandboxed app can save the bookmark for the future access. As a agent program, you can display this so users can revoke / temporarily disable access for a period of time: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/foundation/nsurl/s...

Agree, I think for CLI harness, there is no good alternative, you either have access permit per terminal app (which is not ideal), or I guess that is what Apple means they will "address" it?