Remix.run Logo
▲ mittensc an hour ago

Maybe that's wrong?

The US can't even win a war in the middle east without NATO

What is the US going to do when China starts making their own moves?

▲bluGill 8 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

> The US can't even win a war in the middle east without NATO

That is false. The US could win a war in the middle east without NATO.

The US has consistently chosen not to attempt to do so, but there is every reason to think they could. It is good that the US mostly tries to work with NATO on the middle east (and bad that Trump has not).

The US has also consistently chosen to send minimal ground forces, and when they do send them they are very careful to protect the lives of their soldiers at the expense of winning.

However there remains every reason to think the US could make different decisions and win wars in the middle east alone.

▲rapsey an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Outside the US, NATO countries have very little power projection capabilities. A bit of france, a bit of UK and then nothing.

▲mittensc an hour ago | parent [-]

How's that power projection working in Iran/Yemen?

Would NATO change the equation?

▲bluGill 5 minutes ago | parent [-]

The US has chosen not to project all the power they can. That is send soldiers - likely some to die. However the US has the ability to send them if they want, and could supply them if they did - nobody else has anywhere near that ability ready today.