Remix.run Logo
▲ kelnos 4 hours ago

> Look, I’m not trying to be pro-surveillance state or whatever

Kinda sounds like you are, though.

> but in what universe is a handful of cameras (less than 10 per building)

The article notes 6-7 cameras per floor of one particular building. I'm not sure of the size of each floor of that particular building, so 6-7 cameras per floor may cover very little space, or it may cover a lot. That also says nothing about the coverage in other buildings. Larger buildings probably got more cameras.

Either way, often these sorts of things are set up in phases, with higher concentrations of cameras added later, after the system proves itself as useful.

> My high school also had cameras. Isn’t that rather typical?

There's a big difference between your bog-standard security camera that just records footage to a hard drive somewhere, and these cameras, that send live feeds to an AI company, where the video is presumably automatically analyzed and indexed to allow administrators to effortlessly track people's movements. The AI company may (now or in the future) offer real-time alerts of "suspicious activity", which as we all should know by now probably will have a significant false-positive rate. (But cops will treat alerts as gospel without doing any critical thinking.)

▲Grombobulous 4 hours ago | parent [-]

There were a lot of things in the article I didn’t take at face value due to the obviously non-neutral point of view of the faculty.

For example, why would I assume that MIT is going to violate Massachusetts law and record audio? The cameras possessing microphone hardware is irrelevant if the software doesn’t turn on audio recording.

MIT clearly states in the FAQ linked in the article that audio isn’t recorded:

> No. The security cameras do not record audio. Massachusetts law prohibits recording audio without the knowledge of those being recorded. Additionally, we do not use facial recognition technology with our security cameras.

As you alluded to, 6-7 cameras per floor might be a lot or might not be. I would think it’s not that many: you’re probably getting two to cover stairwells, one for the elevator, one or two to cover a corridor. As soon as a corridor has a bend or runs a certain distance you’re getting another camera. We’re basically at 4 cameras per floor minimum for the smallest multi-story building possible.

▲mccoyb 2 hours ago | parent [-]

How do you know that "we" in "we do not use facial recognition technology" covers ambient.ai, who presumably gets the feeds directly?