Remix.run Logo
program_whiz 7 hours ago

Should they be writing quicksort in assembly as a first step? I think its legitimate in this case given that Jev is likely using the same tools as the example. Showing how easily the core is created using those tools helps to dispel some of the mystery and hype.

Example why its legit:

I just invented a new "Regression Estimate Validator" aka Rev. It takes hundreds of input dimensions, then outputs an interpretable score. Its very fast and statistically robust. Response: Ok but you could just use `pytorch.nn.Linear(d_in, 1)`? True, it is equivalent, but that's concealing millions of lines of hand-tuned math libs, CUDA, python, and other stuff.

The fact that there are many lines of code underpinning the target functionality doesn't make it any harder to use, and doesn't increase the value of the sales pitch for the "new shiny thing" using those few lines of code.

However, I do sympathize with your frustration that people can just say "its 1 line of code" when that line is "invoke API" which is really millions of lines / databases, etc. as a way to dismiss legitimate work without understanding its implications.

iLoveOncall 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> Example why its legit:

Nowhere in your example do you claim that it's written in X lines of code, so that's perfectly fine.

Don't tell me something takes 25 lines of code if it obviously takes much more.

Can you replicate Jev from A to Z in 25 lines? No. Then don't claim to be doing so.