Remix.run Logo
daishi55 17 hours ago

> The LLM did not solve it. It's not intelligent. Humans did,

The humans who are using LLMs to make these groundbreaking advances pretty much unanimously disagree that they lack any intelligence.

krupan 16 hours ago | parent | next [-]

You mean the OpenAI employees? Yeah, I don't see any conflicts of interest there

daishi55 16 hours ago | parent [-]

I’m sorry but you either haven’t been following recent developments or you are pretending not to know the opinions of the top mathematicians on this topic:

> These models are now operating[2] at the level of the top human mathematicians in many parts of the subject and we must assume there is a significant chance of them developing superhuman abilities within a similarly short timeframe.

https://docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/1-xOkPeHmDEdRigT2YcP2...

Instead of desperately clinging to excuses and rationalizations, why don’t you just get used to the fact that these tools are insanely useful for demanding intellectual work, and that is an opinion held by many of the smartest people alive?

krupan 14 hours ago | parent [-]

I won't because it's all so opaque and proprietary and driven by an insane need for OpenAI and Anthropic to provide a return on MASSIVE investment. There is absolutely some smoke and mirrors involved. How much? We don't know. But it sure is exciting to imagine their product is now smarter than humans and they are totally benevolent corporations. I want that to be true as much as anyone, but I have lived too long on this earth to believe it wholeheartedly

jdiff 17 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I haven't seen any statements from them on that topic. Have they actually made some?

daishi55 17 hours ago | parent [-]

From the open letter signed by Terry Tao and other top mathematicians:

> These models are now operating at the level of the top human mathematicians in many parts of the subject and we must assume there is a significant chance of them developing superhuman abilities within a similarly short timeframe.

https://docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/1N6ThWhupvmH0ofSnaxqn...

jdiff 15 hours ago | parent [-]

Superhuman abilities are not "intelligence." 8bit microprocessors exhibit superhuman abilities in different, smaller ways.