Remix.run Logo
StilesCrisis 18 hours ago

As much as it would suck to be one of the 27 unemployed, I don't think the answer is to throw away our calculators and start doing our bookkeeping by hand again. I don't think you need to feel too bad about this. The accountants didn't all disappear when Excel showed up; they just got to work on the more interesting parts of the job, instead of rectifying arithmetic.

lkey 18 hours ago | parent | next [-]

We could create economic systems that prioritized workers over immediate profit.

In this case, a system that aided the displaced workers in finding new positions and acquiring skills that are not simply doordashingfor rent (and still counting that as 'full employment').

In this latest disruption, highly skilled workers are being underemployed in low skill labour and we all lose out. PhD and JD to baristas and uber driver economy.

The federal funding and employment disruption alone will take decades to fix, if ever.

Anywho, you should notice when you participate in creating a massive disruption in many people's lives (to create super-profit for a couple of already wealthy men).

You are never just following orders, don't close your eyes to what you are doing with your life.

And before you 'what about' me. I have refused orders and lost jobs because of it. My only regret is not organizing with other workers beforehand.

mitxela 16 hours ago | parent [-]

Heck, a good start would be ensuring displaced workers still get food and shelter as long as we want.

Those coal miners? They carried the industrial revolution. We should be treating them as retired heroes when we replace the plant with a solar field, not as disgraced losers!

TeMPOraL 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There are many things that could've happened to those 27 people. The company might've decided to reinvest savings into expanding business, and shift those 27 into different roles. Or may have just plain fired them. We can't tell in every case.

But it is worth remembering that the latter is a probable outcome, and that is what our business is, overall. Automation. As in, automating work so it doesn't need people to be done.

ThrowawayR2 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

What's the evidence for that? Did the horses get to work on more interesting parts of the job when the automobile showed up?

StilesCrisis 10 hours ago | parent [-]

You're right. I said "the accountants didn't ALL disappear" but surely, some of them had to endure a career change. But what's the alternative?