I'm in the same spot. It seems like every month a post pops up here that's "I hate passkeys" and most of HN seems to agree.

I use 1Password, but passkeys have made things even easier. I'd rather have them than any 2FA method. So many websites make me use a login/password AND then send me an email or text with a code. Every. Single. Time. You're really telling me you would rather do that than have a passkey?!

And, like you said, passwordless email auth is really terrible.