In a way, Mustafa claims that we shouldn’t allow AIs to compete with humans for the rights and privileges of autonomously shaping the real world.

It’s hard to disagree, especially if one has read the Cantos of Hyperion and made it part of one’s mental model of the long term future.

The book depicts a symbiosis between humans and AIs that feels extremely real and up to date with what is happening in the current neonatal space of AI. As in depicted in the books, we can’t allow AIs to steer autonomously how the world works without humans in the loop, as they don’t have the same incentives as us.

We need more foundational SF works like this to steer our long term expectations regarding AI behaviours.

This point could be made without denying the possibility of AI consciousness.