Remix.run Logo
Rochus 20 hours ago

Great sound quality, definitely better than Suno 5 and 6. It let me download a WAV file which goes unfiltered up to 20kHz (Suno goes to ~15kHz and has more artefacts).

Here is my first attempt: http://rochus-keller.ch/Diverses/Polyphonic_Threshold_1.mp3

And here are some Suno v5 tracks with the same prompt for comparison: https://rochus-keller.ch/?p=1428

All in all, Suno still has much better musicality (or at least had in version 5), but the sound quality of elevenmusic is clearly better.

aabhay 20 hours ago | parent | next [-]

This probably corresponds to compute. ElevenLabs can burn compute for now, Suno can’t.

Rochus 20 hours ago | parent [-]

They also seem to use a different encoding scheme which has more bandwidth and less artefacts up front. If you download a WAV from Suno, you still essentially have MP3 quality, just serialized to a WAV file. The elevenlabs WAV has full audio bandwidth instead and I checked frequency sections with a parametric EQ and noticed that e.g. the cymbals go high up in spectrum (which is not obvious in the given sample song where middle and bass frequencies dominate); with a bit of mastering the result is much better, but I posted the original here. I can also upload the WAV file if needed.

louisjoejordan 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]