Remix.run Logo
pphysch 3 hours ago

In the same way you rely on a keyboard or touchscreen to type this comment. It doesn't mean the tool is the brain behind the work.

Romario77 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

that's not how AI was used in this case. It's more like a professor with assistants.

Professor says the assistants - why don't you dig in this direction, I have a hunch it might produce something valuable. And AI assistant does just that, proving or disproving a hunch. This would take the professor a lot of time if doing by themselves.

vouaobrasil 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Keyboards don't suggest chains of reasoning or words to type. When I press the K key, I know exactly what will happen. It's just a translation layer that gives an output known ahead of time and thus does not impinge upon the creativity of putting words together.

A better example would be playing chess against a player slightly stronger than me and using a chess computer to suggest some good moves. I could win, but it certianly wouldn't be just my brain that wins. It would be an amalgamation of my brain with a machine that suggests good moves.

One cannot simply reason by analogy.

visarga an hour ago | parent [-]

> Keyboards don't suggest chains of reasoning or words to type

My iPhone keyboard does

whimsicalism 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

frankly don’t know how to reply to these sorts of comments anymore

pphysch 3 hours ago | parent [-]

That's usually a good sign you are on shaky ground!

logancbrown 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Obvious false analogy in your earlier argument.

buellerbueller an hour ago | parent [-]

No so obvious to this guy.

whimsicalism an hour ago | parent [-]

it is truly not obvious to you why keyboard isn’t a good analogy for LLM?