Remix.run Logo
IsTom 21 hours ago

If 30-40k timelines are right that's way before agriculture and any kind of "economy". It's firmly hunter-gatherers and there's not much of that to do when it's after sunset.

broken-kebab 20 hours ago | parent [-]

"Economy" by merits of its definition is an applicable term for hunter-gathering societies. And is used widely in this quality, in fact.

Nobody says they couldn't find a time to do carving (existence of the artifact shows they could). The issue in question is comparative value of the time spent on it. Hunting, gathering and concomitant works were certainly both physically and mentally very demanding activities, and their way of life required thoughtful spending of energy. Consequently, whatever irregular pastime they had should have to be extremely valuable. It makes 'toy theory' somewhat unconvincing.

harpiaharpyja 17 hours ago | parent [-]

Pastimes are in fact incredibly valuable. And it's possible the motivations that led to the creation of this artifact wasn't just all about the end product.