Remix.run Logo
paytonjjones a day ago

Yes, memory loss surrounding the hours/days of the treatment is the major side effect.

Care to share the meta-analysis? How does 1/39 compare to the base rate of those with severe depression who did not receive ECT?

sudopsuedo a day ago | parent | next [-]

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30557212/

About 1 in 50 patients may experience a major cardiac event (or death) during the course of ECT

timr a day ago | parent [-]

This isn't responsive to the parent's question, in a way that ironically underscores the point: you can tell me that "1 in 50 patients experience X", but that's meaningless, unless I know what X is in the selected population at baseline.

I don't mean to pick on you. This problem is widespread in academic research.

nightpool a day ago | parent | prev [-]

The stats are from the Wikipedia page for ECT--I'm not sure about the base rate/risk ratio.