Remix.run Logo
HTML Can Do That(chrisburnell.com)
189 points by encyclopedism a day ago | 45 comments
dematz an hour ago | parent | next [-]

This comment by yurishimo should not be [dead], imo

>Just a heads up but datalist is not really a great solution if you need a strong contract. The user can still type whatever they want into the field and there is no fuzzy filtering or typo mitigation. Once you add those requirements, a library that gives you a more fully featured combobox is likely going to make a lot of sense in your project.

It is true! HTML can do a lot of cool stuff, it might get you 100% of the way depending on what you're doing. But if you have a lot of forms where users pick from a value set, and want to enforce no other strings and get a good search experience, datalist does not get you there.

Gualdrapo an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I seem to recall there was a proposal to add such thing to <select>s

bulder 30 minutes ago | parent [-]

I definitely remember seeing a post by a Chromium maintainer talking about starting development on a proof of concept implementation and surveying for semantics.

kotaKat an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

(iirc if you have [showdead] on you can click on the timestamp to the comment and will get a [vouch] option as a reverse-flag, fwiw. i see it and don't have showdead enabled, so enough people have re-vouched it!)

jamescun 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'm that minutia in your statistics that is still rocking NoScript in 2026, enabling JavaScript on a site-by-site basis, but this is increasingly difficult with the modern web.

Hopefully these and others modern HTML features gain adoption, along with realizing perhaps a Single Page Application isn't necessary in most instances.

I don't often have to write frontend code, but when I do, there is very little in terms of interactivity you cannot do with HTML these days, worst case a little sprinkle of something like HTMX.

bee_rider an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Thank goodness you exist, the fingerprinters will be confused as to which one of the two of us went to their website!

jamescun 31 minutes ago | parent [-]

How? There are dozens of us! DOZENS!

Perz1val 13 minutes ago | parent [-]

How would you count?

gunalx 27 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Single page applications are one of the most anoying web patterns i know of. Please just let me have one page for each ting to do so i actually can bookmark it properly.

ThunderSizzle a minute ago | parent | next [-]

Ive made SPAs in Blazor that make it a point to update the URL whenever a "navigation" occurs. I also made it a point to ensure refreshing or loading the URL restored the state.

It's a small problem compared to the ease of use for development you can gain via Blazor, so I don't see any reason not to solve it.

phyzix5761 20 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Once backend and frontend became two separate teams frontend people didn't want to keep asking backend to make logic changes for state, so frontend took things into their own hands. The mistake was making it two separate teams.

zelphirkalt 13 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is part of how I judge how well made or how shitty a website is. If it requires scripts from a dozen third parties, then it usually sucks and one can easily recognize when not much effort has been put into making it.

djoldman 16 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

oh my. Looks like NoScript is way better than what I've been using. Thanks!

https://noscript.net/

hendurhance 4 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Most people use divs for everything now. This is a breath of fresh air.

silvestrov 42 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'd really wish I could force ISO format for the date input as the current "platform native" is confusing for some users when the OS use a different language than the web page that is shown.

For some multi-country companies it makes sense to have all admin pages in English no matter the underlying OS language. Imagine sending a screenshot where the OS date format is different from what everybody else expects from an English page.

hk1337 10 minutes ago | parent [-]

I'd be okay with regional date format for the user but it always submits as ISO 8601 date format.

hk1337 15 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The only one not mentioned I think should be utilized more is properly names in html forms. Everyone has gotten used to just doing things in javascript when a lot of times if you name the fields in a correct way, you can do a simple form post and let the backend validate it with little to no modifications (hopefully none if you did it correctly).

I think the big issue with some of items listed is not all the browsers either implement it or they implement it differently. I'm sure your first instinct will be Safari but Chrome, while it may implement a lot, tends to do it quite different than the others. The date picker in browsers is one feature that comes to mind.

stagas 13 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I started textlog.cc as an experiment to see how far I can go without introducing JS. It turns out, pretty far! If you exclude the Web Push notifications which required a Service Worker script, all the rest is server-side rendered React. As a visitor, with all the hover cards and popovers you would think there is some JS going on, but it’s all HTML-only. I am enjoying very much the constraint and it hasn’t hindered any progress. It’s a proof a lot can be achieved by just HTML.

hk__2 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Related to this, I’d love that HTML natively support sortable tables. This is a common need but every single time I have to reimplement it.

wild_egg 20 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

You want client side table sorting?

It's really easy to do this with server rendered HTML. Put a link with the sort param in the column headers and be done.

krapp 43 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

That's what javascript is supposed to be for. All of this is what javascript is supposed to be for.

HTML describes layout, CSS describes style, JS adds interactivity.

Want sortable tables? Get a jquery plugin and spend five minutes, done.

This was all solved a decade or more ago.

aitchnyu an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Saw Grouped <details>, ctrl+F'd the hidden content and it opened and highlighted the text in Firefox. Was waiting for this fix ever since I learned about details.

hakesson an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yeah, I'm a great fan of both HTML and CSS "can do that". I find more useful things on the CSS side like :has, keyframes and container queries. Why duplicate code when you have it for free :)

Sohcahtoa82 an hour ago | parent [-]

Yeah I've seen a page that described a whole bunch of things you can do with CSS. So many animation options!

jdlshore 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The “hidden until found” feature surprised me. What’s the use case for something like that?

dspillett 5 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

It won't be an intended use case, but it might be a convenient place to put poisoned content for the “benefit” of scrapers…

Though humans will accidentally find it too, so using a details tag with appropriate summary as a warning would be more friendly than just hidden content. It'll still get opened, but the user at least has a way of closing it again afterwards.

Also before using it I'd want to check what old UAs including accessibility tools tend to do when they hit a value that they don't recognise for the hidden="" attribute - would what they don't recognise as a valid value result in defaulting to the content being hidden or visible/read/other?

dofm an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Looks like it's basically like a one way show-hidden mechanism, but the browser's built-in search will pop it open on matches.

So you could use it for additional notes, things like "view pricing terms" or "show exclusions" on product listings — stuff people need to read only when they need to read it — without it being hidden from them if they search for it.

wvbdmp an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Pretty cool! I’ve been using <details> for this. One example would be a collapsible tree hierarchy of our organization that you can CTRL+F and still find collapsed teams and people. Or an accordion, or anything collapsible, really.

seki285 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

One thing that comes to mind is JS-less image preview, clicking on an image thumbnail reveals the full preview.

dspillett 17 minutes ago | parent [-]

Though that wouldn't have a method of closing the full image afterwards, if you have a few thumbnails and want one full to be open at a time (closing when the next is selected).

yoz-y an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think it’s neat but at the same time I’m cautious about implementing an “almost feature” in what’s supposed to be a declarative language.

Now everybody needs to support it and nobody can really use it.

I’m talking about the features in work like media controls on dialog buttons.

bingemaker an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

<img> also supports "srcset" which can make the image component responsive. Hope they add a placeholder to it which can account for loading state.

hollowturtle 31 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

An "HTML Can't Do That" would be hundreds pages long, and at the pace of getting features like dialogs every decade we're limiting ourselfs on any further development and creating serious apps. It wasn't created for apps, it was created for light document formatting. When we will pretend a drawing api we can call directly from webassembly? Outside of web ui frameworks are doing just fine and way better and more performantly than html and dom

gear54rus 30 minutes ago | parent [-]

> When we will pretend a drawing api we can call directly from webassembly?

Hopefully, never. There's enough ad-blocking arms race as it is.

mabini 13 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Just because you can, it doesn't mean you should

hyperhello an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I don’t understand why the group invented these new attributes and methods of action for dialogs that don’t seem relevant to anything else. Was there some silly patent to work around?

esprehn an hour ago | parent [-]

As opposed to what? Not sure what the alternative you're picturing is.

hyperhello an hour ago | parent [-]

popovertarget="example-dialog" popovertargetaction="hide"

It’s all binding. This is what JavaScript is for: dynamic content.

CodesInChaos 25 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What I'd like to see are searchable drop-downs (not to be confused with text input with suggestions).

And the date/time picker controls are too limited for many applications.

bellowsgulch 22 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The older I get, the less I want to use new browser features that have already been somehow possible with existing ones that typically have been around for literal decades.

Adopting them makes a future with multiple browser engines more labor intensive and unlikely as the number of standards targets one is required to support grows and it becomes a game of asking yourself what sites you want your browser to support.

If you don't have a lot of experience in web software, you might think, that's a silly thing to think about, but I think it's that level of maybe exceptional thoughtfulness that has really profound ramifications. If you do have a lot of experience in web software and you think it's silly to think about, you suck.

totallygeeky 17 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I've been tooling with site for years now and I'm always shocked at what can be done with raw HTML. These are some really neat examples, some work a bit funny when it comes to mouse vs. arrow key functionality though (in particular the dropdown/autocomplete), I'm wondering if that's an Edge specific issue or Chromium.

yurishimo 17 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Just a heads up but datalist is not really a great solution if you need a strong contract. The user can still type whatever they want into the field and there is no fuzzy filtering or typo mitigation. Once you add those requirements, a library that gives you a more fully featured combobox is likely going to make a lot of sense in your project.

vlucas an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Very true, and ran into this one specifically myself when going down the "HTML can do this!" road. HTML can NOT, in fact, replace a good combobox with search input. Datalist has significant shortcomings. I wound up using a React island for this single input inside otherwise normal HTML, despite my own objections, because it really it just that much better than the native options.

sarchertech an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There’s still browser/OS typo mitigation.

reaperducer an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

That's the whole sanitize vs. validate argument debate that keeps coming up.

How you handle it is project-dependent. But if you're doing a real web site, not an SPA, you can show an error/help page, or re-load the current page with the error/help message.