Does it matter? People get caught up on LLM this and sure, a professional beats an LLM currently but I'd rather read some well written LLM text over some poorly written human effort

If it matters is subjective. But personally I stop reading when I notice it’s AI text because there is never anything in it worth reading. It’s just a prompt expanded in to paragraphs of filler text.

This kind of tool doesn’t need a whole Apple style marketing page to sell you on it.

It also signals effort to me, when I see vibeslop text I know the project most likely is a one shot weekend project full of issues which won’t be resolved. I’ve seen good examples of AI use in open source, and those projects write the readme and website copy without AI.

Your LLM text is obviously not well written if we spot it after 2 seconds. I won’t read it, doesn’t matter how beautiful it is, it’s just pure cringe, I notice, roll my eyes, close the tab. Please give me the poorly written human effort. Is it really that hard to spend 10minutes reading what you produced to see if that feels genuine?

It matters to me because I notice and I hate it.

I read plenty of not-obviously-AI-generated text and I much prefer doing that, even if it’s not from a professional.

It’s not about the quality of the text itself. If Claude was one person with a human level of output, Claude would probably be considered decent at writing.

But when I have to read the same genre of slop on 1 million different sites it gets really really annoying imo.

> I'd rather read some well written LLM text over some poorly written human effort

I could not disagree more.