No, you are wrong. Or at least, incomplete.

The comment I replied to said "I need Claude because it's better than no AI.

That's like saying "I need the Porsche because it's better than no car".

Making a "car vs no car" argument is not an argument for an expensive car. Making an argument for an expensive car, requires both car vs no car, and expensive car vs any car. This is what I was pointing out above.

My argument may be wrong, but I myself am just fine, thank you.