Remix.run Logo
marginalia_nu 2 hours ago

I did, and I still don't get why you would want this monstrosity over a structured append-only log file. If you want to index the data, you can do that when you roll over the file. That way you get the exact same robustness guarantees, without the insane architecture.

Like ultimately it isn't even fast, journalctl is so bad at rendering text that it's approximately still as slow as seeking in a 400 MB .log-file using less.

Anyone with any sort of scale where you actually need indexing immediately drops journald and uses loki or elasticsearch instead. Journald is not even remotely a contender in that space.

otterley 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> Anyone with any sort of scale where you actually need indexing immediately drops journald and uses loki or elasticsearch instead. Journald is not even remotely a contender in that space.

That I agree with. I don't personally use journalctl much these days, particularly now that practically everything's a container and all their logs are getting shipped off-host for indexing. But I get why, 14 years ago, it was considered a good idea.