Regarding ulterior motives - these permissions are 'performative' in that anything you can give it permission to do, it already has the ability to do. They're app level - not OS level. So if they wanted to do something, it wouldn't require you to give permission.

▲

frogulis an hour ago | parent | next [-]

To be clear, I'm not accusing Anthropic of being evil black hats trying to break my computer, I'm accusing (or rather suspecting) them of pushing me towards some kind of product lock-in by making my preferred "sceptical at-arms-length user" workflow more annoying.

▲

eru 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The app is split into multiple layers.

Just like your browser can do everything already, but only lets websites use specific features.

	▲	somenameforme 2 hours ago \| parent [-]
		Right and you rely on that browser to enforce those protections. But if the browser itself was working against you, then the permissions you tell it to give (or not) become meaningless. A good example there is trying to turn off "telemetry" on Windows.