Remix.run Logo
tialaramex 6 hours ago

Yeah, likewise the Breitling Emergency is big because it's an actual working 406 MHz Personal Locator Beacon. In principle that's all you need to have a rescue team come get you if you, I dunno, crashed your plane on a desert island or you broke your leg while hiking in Siberia, or whatever. Of course if you're the sort of person who wears a wristwatch which costs as much as a car you probably aren't doing anything like that, but you could be and maybe you're an elite solo who "travels light" and so you couldn't pack a conventional much cheaper PLB.

I can't imagine Breitling sells very many of these, they're huge heavy watches, if you're The Rock they probably look fine on your arm but the average tough guy can't justify owning a watch this expensive and if you're the 5'4" female CEO of a famous company you can afford the Emergency but it looks ridiculous and feels like you're carring a boulder on your wrist.

Like Concorde, sometimes we prove something was possible but it turns out it was unavoidably too expensive and annoying for it to make much sense in the market.

[Edit: Fix spelling of Concorde]

sakree 6 hours ago | parent [-]

you would be surprised how large and passionate the watch community is. In the world of watches that breitling is big, but not really that big. It is quite a popular watch, and not that expensive : https://www.chrono24.com/breitling/emergency--mod21.htm?dose...

tialaramex 4 hours ago | parent [-]

Notice that for the actual purpose of rescue only what they're calling "Gen2" actually works. The earlier devices which make up most of the linked examples are pretty, and would doubtless make interesting jewellery for a man at a society dinner or in the boardroom, but they do almost nothing if you're alone somewhere and need rescuing today.

Once upon a time, decades ago, a "beacon" is just a primitive radio transmitter which when activated produces a clearly man-made signal (it sounds like a siren basically if you're listening to it). This works pretty good if people nearby know to look for it. Then COSPAS SARSAT is a "peaceful use" satellite technology, put some satellites up above the Earth, they relay the chosen emergency frequencies and now a human operator can "hear" that beacon from hundreds of miles away. So that's all the original Emergency does. Rescue this way was sometimes a long-shot, but you did not have better options.

But obviously now we can do a lot better, so eventually COSPAS SARSAT deprecated and then eventually eliminated that relay technology in favour of 406 MHz digital beacons. So now it can tell which beacon has been triggered, and you can add stuff like contact details to a database for the rescuers. This way when they get a beacon they can see the signal is Steve Smith, solo mountaineer, here's a contact number for Steve's mum, so before we commit a mountain rescue team to 18 hours of work we can verify whether Steve is currently up a mountain [maybe in urgent need of rescue] or whether he lost that beacon last month and is at home now watching Netflix.

Your point is well taken - I just wanted to be absolutely clear for anybody who might get one of these that the original Emergency is now basically just pretty and only a modern "Gen2" Emergency "works" for its stated purpose.