Remix.run Logo
bell-cot 2 hours ago

Not an astrophysicist, but I'm thinking 5 AU could quickly fry the Earth - because it takes very little in the way of solar comets, asteroids, and dust to build a temporary accretion disk around such a black hole. That disk might have a temperature of >1M degrees. Plus the dynamo effects of the disk's interactions with the solar magnetic field? Yeah. 5 ly sounds much safer.

ben_w an hour ago | parent [-]

> Yeah. 5 ly sounds much safer.

Well yeah.

I clearly could've phrased this better though: I was aiming for "here is an example distance which *is* bad", not as it appears to have been understood "here is the distance where it is *not* bad".

bell-cot 33 minutes ago | parent [-]

I mostly noticed your "might have an unplesant climate impact by increasing the eccentricity of our orbit", and thought that'd be the least of Earth's worries.

Black hole gravity is ruthless about turning nearby mass into deadly fireworks.

cindyllm 31 minutes ago | parent [-]

[dead]