> Personally I think the tax authorities ought to take the line that a company posting serial losses like this is clearly not a viable, ongoing concern and ought to be wound up.

Tax authorities don't need to do this. Investors will. Where will the money come from? If there's no future prospects, it will cease operations.

> If Starbucks UK is a loss-making venture, they should have some explaining to do when they're opening new branches.

I like how discussion of taxes turned everyone into a fierce defender of profit maximization. Nothing about adding back to the community, paying decent wages, etc.

▲

Swenrekcah 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> I like how discussion of taxes turned everyone into a fierce defender of profit maximization. Nothing about adding back to the community, paying decent wages, etc.

You are fundamentally missing the issue. What most of these multinationals do is to extract value from the places they operate but then move all the profit (in the books) to another tax jurisdiction, thereby not contributing to the community where they operate. Furthermore this undercuts local businesses, further impoverishing the area.

Global commerce and cooperation unlocks some truly great opportunities but the finance people can really bring ruin if allowed free reign.

▲

perpetuallunch 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The only sane argument to be made against this practice is that governments should make their tax systems more favourable to companies operating in their jurisdiction so they have no reason to move their profits to a more favourable jurisdiction.

Australia has, if I understand correctly, the highest corporate profit tax rate in the OECD. Higher than New Zealand, the US, Canada, the UK, Ireland, Japan, Turkey, China, Greece, Belgium, Denmark, Sweden, Iran, Zimbabwe, Iceland, Finland, Ukraine, Hungary, Qatar, Iceland, anyway…

Why wouldn’t you expatriate your profits and retain your loses as a multinational operating in Australia?

Australia is increasingly and rapidly driving itself toward a future where higher taxes result in lower tax revenues as individuals, business, and corporations pick up their capital and leave for jurisdictions with more favourable regulations and taxation.

Governments shouldn’t aim to maximise taxation, that always kills innovation and the entrepreneurial spirit. They should aim to optimise taxation to a point where businesses flourish and infrastructure is built and maintained, and otherwise generally not be heard from much at all.

▲

bko 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

What value do they extract? They provide a good or service to denizens. Unless of course you believe in a serf model of government in which people are an asset of the state and everything should serve the states goals.

	▲	perpetuallunch 3 hours ago \| parent [-]
		This is increasingly, and worryingly, becoming an ideology people are being swept up by. It doesn’t help that there are Card Carrying Socialist activists in our public school system in Australia, indoctrinating kids in to a politically and economically bent out of shape ideology. I don’t believe many Australians are aware of just how dangerously few steps away from the mouldy bread and rotting fish head soup lines version of “equality” we really are. Since when has government, of any sort, been a reliable arbiter of truth or wisdom? P.J. O’Rourke would be turning in his grave. Giving money and power to government is like giving whiskey and car keys to teenage boys. Socialists in Schools: https://www.victoriansocialists.org.au/campaigns/socialists-...

▲

Nursie 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> If there's no future prospects, it will cease operations.

That's the point, there are plenty of future prospects, but the company is playing accounting games to hide the profits.

> I like how discussion of taxes turned everyone into a fierce defender of profit maximization.

No, we're just calling bullshit on the whole thing because we're tired of wealthy multinationals dodging taxes in our countries. That's how they should be contributing.

▲

perpetuallunch 3 hours ago | parent [-]

There are counties that have zero percent corporate profits tax.

Be like them and the corporations won’t have a need to offshore their profit.

The alternative is One World Government, which, in its lesser form, empire, has a nasty habit rapidly turning quite sour.

	▲	Nursie 41 minutes ago \| parent [-]
		This has to be one of the most ludicrous, cartoonishly libertarian things I've ever read. No thanks! I'd rather have a functioning society!