Remix.run Logo
defgeneric 21 hours ago

The "3 years" figure has been repeated endlessly and yet the same H100s are making today roughly what they did in Jan 2024...

horticulturist 20 hours ago | parent [-]

How long does a train track last? Does a fiber optic cable last? Both are greater than 30 years, both will persist (relatively well) without use, and the benefits of scrapping or removing them are minimal. This allowed future companies to take advantage of them. Even if GPUs running at high load last five years, if the data center they are in goes bankrupt (because the AI bubble bursts), it’s likely they’ll be stripped and sold to make way for more productive CPU-based uses and to recover some of the cost of the bankruptcy. The surrounding buildings and infrastructure will have longer use, but it doesn’t translate to a net future benefit with AI.

tim333 3 hours ago | parent [-]

That reminds me of saying the early Google was doomed because they put all their money into cheap pcs acting as servers - how long do those last? But the enduring value was Google dominating search which was worth billions/trillions, not the heaps of pcs.

Same here - the main value is in dominating AI or something like that, not in the stack of hardware.