He's on to us, boys! Call in a code 43.

(Sorry, I'm in a crappy mood, but what on Earth are we supposed to take away from this? Everyone who disagrees with you is secretly an idiot, or worse, they're smart enough to know they're idiots but too proud to admit it?)

On a more helpful note, I think your "confusion" if honest can probably be resolved by realizing that "skeptics" are not a monolith.