Haha, I know its not the same but at least they have the 3d rotating skull!

Here ya go - Internet Archive backed up a metric shit-ton (I believe is the correct measure word) of animated GIFs from geocities:

https://gifcities.org/search?q=tiger&offset=0&page_size=200

I should add a little JS snippet on my site that injects random geocities GIFs every October 26th which was when the service died back in 2009.

Thank you, I couldn't find it with google and I was starting to think the internet had forgotten it in its steady decline. Whether that's a symptom or the cause of the decline, I can't be sure. But there's still hope!!