Remix.run Logo
billyp-rva an hour ago

> Substack gives you a way to push content to your subscribers without an intermediary deciding what they get to read.

How do we know they won't start limiting your reach in the future? That's the path basically every other platform has gone down.

Bratmon an hour ago | parent | next [-]

The entire pitch of Substack is "You can export the email addresses of your current subscribers at any time"

So if they stop doing the "email my subscribers whenever I post" step, another service will fill the gap pretty quick.

rsingel an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Substack notes is non exportable; the newsletter now no longer have a link to read it on your site on substack and instead link to the substack app, and subscriptions started in the app pay Substack through Apple and Google and you can't export them.

Substack has become a roach motel but they pretend otherwise

sixtyj 9 minutes ago | parent [-]

Thanks for this.

I can hear Substack marketing saying that “We don’t have any intention to put you into a vendor-lock.”

I had a lot of discussions with companies about their marketing.

Why do you upload your events’ photos to FB instead of your site?

Why do you have news on LI feed and don’t make it a post on your site as well?

Do you think they can hear it? :)

Substack is going to become a similar service as FB, LI are… no possibility to export your data easily or not at all.

ImJamal an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If Substack stops supporting that feature you would end up losing all of your subscribers when you move to the alternative unless you happen to have an up to date export.

Forgeties79 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Until they make it more difficult to export lol that’s the real canary in the coal mine if you ask me.

throw1234567891 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

When they will, you’ll be free to take action.

shimman 39 minutes ago | parent [-]

Yeah and having a site is a way to mitigate that risk...

carlosjobim an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> How do we know they won't start limiting your reach in the future?

You can never know anything about what anybody will do in the future? You can't. Why do hackers always use this argument against everything?

bryanrasmussen 11 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Hackers always use this argument against everything because you can in fact know some things about what one person, yourself, will do in the future.

Thus they argue that you should not trust your things to other people but do it yourself, because, barring major illness, you can reasonably assume that you will try to do what is best for yourself in the future.

autoexec 39 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

> You can never know anything about what anybody will do in the future?

You absolutely can know something about what someone will do in the future. You gain those insights by looking at their past and present behavior and the behavior of others in similar circumstances. Hackers tend to be pretty good at pattern recognition and can often see where things are heading. Enshittification is a pretty smart bet.

c16 42 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Gmail has categories. So they already are.