Remix.run Logo
estearum a day ago

Wait you think there are so many exceptions for rape and incest because of the political power of the rape and incest lobby?

Holy fuck. Even for someone who has quickly earned a name for himself and his insane takes, this is a strong entry.

Bravo, ButlerianJihad!

ButlerianJihad a day ago | parent [-]

Think of it this way:

Incest is not always consensual, and incest may be intra-family molestation or sexual abuse. In those cases, certainly the "rape exceptions" cover mothers who seek to abort their unborn children.

However, incest is not always non-consensual, such as between ordinary adults who just cross a "bright line boundary" and have a sexual affair that they may or may not regret. So is this why there are so many exceptions for "non-rape incest" abortions? Why, to avoid being exposed to shame or having, for example, siblings need to co-parent their rather illicit offspring that nobody will talk about? What's unique about "non-rape incest" that it requires its own carved-out exception that is so often baked into all the laws prohibiting other kinds of abortions?

estearum a day ago | parent [-]

You are incorrect. The logic behind a separate incest exception is that the vast majority of incest is at least coercive/groomed if not forcible rape, but qualifying for the rape exception would require meeting the significant and probably-not-achievable standard of proving rape months after it happened. And in many incest cases that means specifically "proving rape" after years and years "intimate relations," given again that most incest cases are coerced/groomed for years or decades.

Contrast with the simple prenatal paternity test.