Remix.run Logo
TSiege 11 hours ago

"I love lax security features therefore you should too." Defaults should be safe and risky action should be done at the user's own discretion

apetresc 11 hours ago | parent | next [-]

This isn't really security-related. The "AskUserQuestion" hook in question here is not the one that gets used for authorizing actions. That's a completely separate mechanism that is unaffected by this 60-second timer thing.

What this is referring to are those follow-up "here's two plausible alternative ways to do this, which one do you prefer?" questions you sometimes get, and usually at the beginning of a planning session when presumably you're still actively involved in the session. They get exponentially less likely as the turn goes on.

Maybe it's a good default, maybe it's not, I'll wait to pass judgment. But it's not security-related except in contrived scenarios you could construct where one side of an A-or-B UserQuestion has security implications that aren't caught by any other safeguard. I haven't ever really experienced that in practice.

solenoid0937 11 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

It's not security related. If you aren't running agents in a sandbox today, that's a "you" problem.

It's purely architecture/design related and the last thing anyone wants is coming back at the end of the day to find their agent didn't make progress because it was stuck on a response.

You can always redirect the agent or scrap its work, you can't undo the lost time.