Remix.run Logo
maiti_ma 2 hours ago

`Mencius said: "The trouble with people is that they are too fond of being teachers to others."`

I never thought about this but I really believe it to be true and would love to know why is that. For example, whenever I want to get an interaction going with very small kids, I would pretend to not know something and they'd be super happy to teach me - works every time.

jdw64 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

People feel competent and important when they teach others. This desire is so primal, as you said, that it can even be seen in young children. That's why people unconsciously try to teach others, and it often creates problems in relationships.

The reason arguments are dangerous is that while they look like an attempt to correct someone's knowledge, in reality they easily mix with the desire to place yourself in the 'teacher's seat.'

However, Confucianism places great value on teaching, and at first glance this might seem contradictory to Mencius's words. But it explains that the purpose of teaching is different. Good teaching aims to bring out the best in others and nurture them, and it should come after self-cultivation. On top of that, it requires the other person's consent, such as when they are in need. Bad teaching, on the other hand, is about self-display, the desire to feel superior, and interfering without being asked.

In reality, it's hard to draw a perfect line between the two, but I think the effort is to keep trying.

mi_lk an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

I can see how one’s tendency to preach being associated with their ego

I would also make a distinction between kids’ ‘teaching’ behaviors you describe and the one in Mencius’s quote

jbboehr an hour ago | parent [-]

A slightly more charitable interpretation might be: sharing useful information creates the possibility of reciprocity.