junk food is a common misconception about electronic music with ppl who have only listened to trash versions of it on social media.

▲

keiferski 3 hours ago | parent [-]

I don’t mean electronic music writ large, I mean AI generated music.

Electronic music is probably my favorite genre, broadly. But there’s a human behind the machine, not a random collection of patterns. To use a concrete example: NIN is about 1000% more interesting because of who Trent Reznor is, and not because it’s merely good music.

This disconnect is much more of an issue with say, country or bluegrass or jazz. To divorce those from the musician and their cultural context is to miss the whole point.

▲

someguyiguess 3 hours ago | parent [-]

There's a human behind AI-generated music too. A human writes the prompts. Your distinction seems rather arbitrary.

▲

keiferski 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Typing “make me an electronic guitar song about a bad breakup” is a whole lot different than learning to play the instrument yourself and conveying your own emotions from your real experience into a song that you write and perform.

If you can’t see how these are fundamentally different things, I don’t know what to tell you.

	▲	neutronicus 2 hours ago \| parent \| next [-]
		I think a lot of songs about bad break-ups were written by talented musicians without actual experience of a bad break-up, riffing on the corpus of songs they'd heard about bad break-ups. Like, a lot of times you're just engaging with someone's desire to have made a song, and what they felt about some songs that someone else made.
	▲	visarga 2 hours ago \| parent \| prev \| next [-]
		Even if you generate the soundtrack, if you set the lyrics it can be great music. At least for one person, who chose the lyrics. I set some poems on music and I absolutely love the results.
	▲	esikich 2 hours ago \| parent \| prev [-]
		Do you really think that's the only way to do it? I spend hours refining the output, slicing things up, redoing certain parts, tossing it into the DAW and compressing, adding effects, etc. I mean, if you think one shot prompts are the only way to use AI to make music fine, but you're being intentionally obtuse.